- Joined
- Nov 3, 2011
- Messages
- 47,912
I like him a lot. Just don't know that he would leave a nice spot at his alma mater for Miami.
forums
OK, if the trio of Chud, Butch and Schiano are the top 3...
- Thread starter k9cane
- Start date
I like him a lot. Just don't know that he would leave a nice spot at his alma mater for Miami.
Advertisement
FullyERicht
Thunderdome
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2013
- Messages
- 5,591
What exactly makes him a great coach? MIAMI IS NOT IN A POSITION TO HIRE A COLLEGE COORDINATOR OR 35 YEAR OLD JAG WITH FIVE YEARS OF TOTAL COACHING.
If you don't understand why such a hire would be beyond idiotic you should read more and post less.
Advertisement
MAGIC CITY CANE
Sophomore
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2011
- Messages
- 718
Lulz at the love for Butch Davis. There a lot of people in high stress / demanding professions that are better at age 62 then they were in their prime / late 40s? Especially when they've been off and on retired for about half of the previous 15 years. I'm thinking he just might not be as good a talent evaluator or recruiter as he was in his prime. Lot different recruiting environment in Miami today than in 2000. But hey, he'll just step right in with a staff that he doesn't have (because, cough, cough, he hasn't coached in 3 years) and not miss a beat.
MedleyCane
Senior
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2011
- Messages
- 10,304
I get the impression Strong's camp is trying to leverage the job opening at UM for salary at Texas.
FullyERicht
Thunderdome
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2013
- Messages
- 5,591
I didn't realize Jimbo was at Miami.
If Jimbo had failed, they were one coach removed from greatness, and have the money to simultaneously pay a buyout while affording a solid replacement.
Miami has shown repeatedly that a) this job is too demanding for a rookie or green HC 2) will not spend good money when dealing with paying the remainder of fired coaches contract.
This is Miami. This isn't Auburn with unlimited pockets and buying whatever recruits. You simply cannot take the risk on a 35 year old who coached 2 years as OC and then 1 year as a HC TOTAL.
NO
Advertisement
Can I dream
Kliff Kingsbury.. only make 2.1 million... Over him 3mill and ask him to show James Coley the way..
Josh Heupel...making 500k but Coley might feel disrespected a younger coach got the job over him and resign.
No retreads except Butch... his ability to stockpile talent could change our landscape once again.
Kliff Kingsbury.. only make 2.1 million... Over him 3mill and ask him to show James Coley the way..
Josh Heupel...making 500k but Coley might feel disrespected a younger coach got the job over him and resign.
No retreads except Butch... his ability to stockpile talent could change our landscape once again.
Last edited:
Martycane
Sophomore
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2012
- Messages
- 1,001
They can pay the comp with the comp they get for Golden leaving..,
Shinyheadman
Sophomore
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2013
- Messages
- 1,289
No on Schianno. He had too much negativity this season for him to be a possibility. I would consider Butch is he showed that he wanted it, I don't want to bring in a guy who doesn't know if he even wants to coach any more. I like Rob in this case. Kirby Smart though would still be the guy I would try to make a call to.
- Joined
- Jan 6, 2013
- Messages
- 711
Interesting how you launch into personal insults if anyone disagrees with you...
You should watch Texas Tech play if you have to ask what makes him a great coach. Based on the content of your posts, I doubt you watch much football anyway. And ruling out any candidate merely because they are a college coordinator is silly. Why limit any options?
Typing in all caps doesn't make what you say any more correct or factual. Oh, and perhaps you should take your own advice and read more and post less.
Advertisement
SFbayCane
All American
- Joined
- Nov 3, 2011
- Messages
- 18,940
I'd put Petrino slightly ahead of Butch...but if not, yea that's the order I'd go with.
weownfsu
Move to FCS
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2011
- Messages
- 12,423
Butch
Chud
Schiano
Schiano's act is dumb, but he won with lots of South Florida kids at Rutgers. He could "connect" with them and he brings a good rolodex. I just don't see him as a guy who would maximize our talent that well. He had some pretty talented teams by the end of his tenure at Rutgers and only went over 10 wins once. I think people are underselling Schiano. There's a lot of good qualities about him
But Butch is basically Schiano on steroids and already knows how to win big here. With Chud we would be a really well coached team and he could hire an excellent staff. My only question is whether he'd want to pound the ever living **** out of other teams or take it easy on them. The latter does not work @ UM.
Chud
Schiano
Schiano's act is dumb, but he won with lots of South Florida kids at Rutgers. He could "connect" with them and he brings a good rolodex. I just don't see him as a guy who would maximize our talent that well. He had some pretty talented teams by the end of his tenure at Rutgers and only went over 10 wins once. I think people are underselling Schiano. There's a lot of good qualities about him
But Butch is basically Schiano on steroids and already knows how to win big here. With Chud we would be a really well coached team and he could hire an excellent staff. My only question is whether he'd want to pound the ever living **** out of other teams or take it easy on them. The latter does not work @ UM.
Advertisement
BlackKeysFan
Sophomore
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2013
- Messages
- 984
You're crazy. Dude had North Carolina chock full of 1st Round talent. North Carloina. He hasn't lost anything as far as evals go. He will always have that.
- Joined
- Nov 3, 2011
- Messages
- 14,701
He has won at Vanderbilt an historically bad program. Plus, he has done it in the SEC during a time that the SEC has won 7 straight national championships and playing for its 8. Plus, he is a leader of men and recruits at a high level and against BAMA, LSU, UGA, USC and etc.
Advertisement