forums

Ivins new recruiting info

KrazyCane said:
this idea that you need a qb commit every cycle is some made up CIS bs
Click to expand...

Exactly. All about quality and properly spaced out quality at that. If you add a junk QB just because you feel you HAVE to and then 2 current QBs transfer because you've exacerbated any possible depth/opportunity issues in a now overcrowded QB Room then it's a freakin' net negative.
 

Advertisement
Number1CanesFan said:
Yeah, but they are not going to transfer to a school to be somebody's backup. Otherwise, they'd just stay put. Grad transfer is out, unless there is a real opportunity to be the starter. It only works when the guy transferring lines up to become the starter after he sits out a year. Take Jacob Eason for example, When he lost his starting job at Georgia, I called out his transfer to Washington several months before it happened. He's from Washington. Jake Browning is a senior. Eason will will step in as the starting QB in 2019 after sitting out the 2018 season and have 2 years of eligibility left. This is the type of situation where a QB transfer works and makes sense.
Click to expand...

For every Will Grier and Jacob Eason who actually end up starting after a transfer there are a ton of Malik Zaire, Ryan Williams, Jake Heaps, Malik Henry. Kids transfer for all kinds of reasons...and if were looking for a QB itll probably morenin the sense of looking for a body rather than a rare transfer potential stud like grier or eason.
 
g8rh8rMD said:
That's fine as a blanket statement, and I'm going to take your stat at face value and assume it is accurate. But, just because there is a robust sheer number of QB's looking to transfer, in general on an average year, doesn't mean there is one out there right now who could come in and take this team to another level this year and also not destroy the chemistry and foundation that CMR is building. A robust market does not necessarily mean that we need to take one, nor does it mean that what we need is available to us.
Click to expand...

Its actually a higher # than listed. And i wasnt saying we were looking for a starter but certainly there is a qb out there who could provide an equal value to a young raw QB like MJjr.

https://www.foxsports.com/college-f...ua-tagovailoa-michigan-dylan-mccaffrey-013017
Top 50qbs x 4 years = 200 QBs....100 of which transferred.
 
Last edited:
Number1CanesFan said:
Not taking a QB won't prevent a transfer. Between Perry, Weldon, and Williams, at least one of them is going to transfer next year. Depending on who wins the starting QB position this year or next. If starter is Perry --> Weldon transfers. If starter is Weldon --> Perry transfers. If starter is Williams --> Weldon and Perry transfer and William's would be the only QB on the roster at the end of 2018 if he wins the job this year.

A big factor is if William's redshirts. It would be better for the program if Williams redshirts. Otherwise we could wind up with an Alabama situation where all their QBs transferred after Jalen Hurts won the job as a freshman. Not getting a QB this cycle could wind up a disaster.
Click to expand...

I would say it worked out okay for Alabama and they would agree, especially since they didn’t bother taking a scholarship QB this last cycle. I do agree it would be better for program if Williams redshirts.
 
Advertisement
You have to take a QB every cycle. Has Ivins said anything about what the DT board looks like? I know we have Daxon in the fold and we just recently offered Holley from Buford but outside of that idk where we stand. Need at least 3 maybe 4.
 
I'm hoping & remaining optimistic that we land MJ Jr, but in all honesty I think he'd be a great Spread QB & playing for Frost in his system would be enticing especially if he'll actually play early. With that said, I think we get MJ.

And the strategy of not taking a QB this class is not a good one, idk why some of you fundamentalist have to always man the shields & defend every decision made by the staff as if they're infallible.

They're the best staff we've had in a long long time & all of us are extremely appreciative of what they've done to rebuild us into a legit contender, that doesn't mean they're incapable of making bad moves from time to time. Not taking a QB this class is a bad move. Doesn't mean anybody needs to be fired or anything like that, just means it's a decision to bank on hoping one of the 3 youngins stick around despite hardly ever playing.

Playing the Transfer market for QB's isn't the smartest way to go about things to find a QB. Idc how many 5-stars are available for transfer, you always want your own kids that you developed to run your system.

This refusal to develop our young QB's & getting them legit in game reps has to progress. It ain't the 90's anymore, these QB's are not sitting for 3 years waiting their turn.
 
TallyCane said:
You have to take a QB every cycle. Has Ivins said anything about what the DT board looks like? I know we have Daxon in the fold and we just recently offered Holley from Buford but outside of that idk where we stand. Need at least 3 maybe 4.
Click to expand...

Said Braylen ingraham from STA is a Cane Lean. Like Tyler Davis from Wekiva but he's a OSU lean. Kicking tires on Derrick Hunter and Quashon Fuller FSU commit.
 
Advertisement
TallyCane said:
You have to take a QB every cycle. Has Ivins said anything about what the DT board looks like? I know we have Daxon in the fold and we just recently offered Holley from Buford but outside of that idk where we stand. Need at least 3 maybe 4.
Click to expand...
Long article but Miami looking at, just names on the board, to go with Daxon at DT:
Ingraham
T Davis
Jalar Holly
Fuller
Calija Kancey
I think Hunter was mentioned too, mutual interest.

To go with Williams at DE:
Boggle
Sumerall
Jahfari Harvey
Jermaine Johnson
Weaver
Colby Wooden
 
Everybody freaking out because he said IF we don't land MJJ(who we lead for) we MIGHT punt on a QB this year. Nothing in there is definitive but everyone is acting like it is. **** all the rest of the good news in that update, we MIGHT pass on a QB IF we don't land the one we lead for, so let's ***** and moan.

If there isn't one they like enough to seriously target then I am 100% fine with waiting and checking out the transfer market after this season. And that's if we don't land MJJ. Let's put the pitchforks down for a few.
 
Lexcane said:
Taking a qb this year wont help qb depth at all genius. All you’re doing is adding another transfer to the list. It might make you feel better temporarily but all you’re going to end up with is two transfers instead of one.
Click to expand...

Unless you have a walk-on you LOVE or are ready to give a scholly...Then no that is faulty logic.

Because the transfer could come this winter/spring/or next summer...So why leave yourself only 2 scholly qb next year? Pretty simple.
 
Advertisement
Storm said:
Long article but Miami looking at, just names on the board, to go with Daxon at DT:
Ingraham
T Davis
Jalar Holly
Fuller
Calija Kancey
I think Hunter was mentioned too, mutual interest.

To go with Williams at DE:
Boggle
Sumerall
Jahfari Harvey
Jermaine Johnson
Weaver
Colby Wooden
Click to expand...
We out for Sorrells?
 
TheSwagger1 said:
Did the NCAA put a cap on transfers or ???

I haven't heard that.

Stack competition, let the best stay and losers leave. I don't give a **** about depth, I'm looking for our next starter. We don't have anyone on the roster that's a lock to be the guy.
Click to expand...
Transfers count as Initial Counters.
We have 3 IC's remaining from 2018 class. That means for 2019, we can bring in 28 NEW players total. Thats including Signees and transfers. So yes, there is a limit to how many transfers we can or should get/go for.
 
orange&green84 said:
Who said we'd be set back a decade? Having said that, if the hypothetical situation occurs where Jarren takes over this year and Perry and Weldon are seeking transfers, then who's backing him up going forward (because Rosier's gone after this year).

QBs transfer the most out of any other position.
Click to expand...

Deejay.

He's a really good receiver, he's a really good running back, and he could take up the slack.

No way Perry AND Weldon both transfer out.

The only thing Deejay can't play is DT, and I'm not real sure on that one. I bet he could put on quite a show at DT!
 
Advertisement
Storm said:
Ivins on Paradise camp. He said the staff was gonna be more selective inviting only targeted recruits and uncommitables for evals.

Also said this would be the most star studded coaches.
Click to expand...
What people dont realize is thats precisely what paradise camp is. People confuse the camp aspect of it with paradise in itself. How we bill it is as a underclassmen camp for invites and walk ins. But the main part of it is strictly invite only from players weve offered and ones we need to evaluate for this upcoming recruiting class or underclassmen we loved the day before after evals and want to see how they compete with other elite recruits. Technically weve done nothing but that since the first one when we had an open camp the first day. Also while i will say ivins is probably the most informed reporter we have now thats really not saying much. Hes clueless on a bunch of things he speaks on. Lastly numbers may be great to have at qb but more than numbers we NEED depth. One of nkosi or cade will transfer. Regardless we need to ensure our eventual back up is a kid more than capable of stepping in and running our offense fluidly. A back up at qb shouldnt simply mean hes nowhere near as good... none of our qbs(malik included)should be exempt of having to prove themselves on the field at this level.
 
Last edited:
Well, if Feagles is punting our decision to not get a QB will work out in the opposite direction and we end up with a QB better than MJJ.
 
orange&green84 said:
Absolutely horrid if we punt on a QB this cycle. You need 1 every cycle.
Click to expand...
Bad idea, because there's a decent chance at least one guy leaves. Well, Rosier IS leaving after the season, and if Williams wins the job sooner rather than later, I wouldn't be shocked to see Perry or Weldon go. As soon as we know MJJ is or isn't coming, we should adjust our recruiting accordingly. We should always take one, since QB is the one spot where kids transfer out at a very high rate. It would be flirting with disaster not taking one.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top