Some names to watch before it’s deleted

[TrumpyCane]

TrumpyCane wants people to know at one point every great OC hired to college or the NFL didn’t have experience calling plays but there’s a reason they were hired to do so

 

[TheOriginalCane]

The Maude’s think this is a great time to unban our favorite Arkansas troll after multiple attempts to get on the board. @jlobob being the latest attempt.

jlobob? Is that like the hillbilly Jennifer Lopez?

 

[AbsoluteUnit]

The way to accomplish 5 coaches with Brady as OC is there are 2 WR's coach's which also coaches TE's because that is how they pulled it off at LSU. Field is not official yet for an on the field role.

1. OC/WR BRADY
2. Co-OC/WR McClendon
3. OL/AHC/RGC Mirabal
4. QB/PGC Coley
5. RB Smith or whoever

Amen. Personally, this is my dream staff right here. Brady/Bmac coach TEs during passing drills and Mirabal coaches during blocking drills.

 

[Canes Legacy]

TrumpyCane wants people to know at one point every great OC hired to college or the NFL didn’t have experience calling plays but there’s a reason they were hired to do so

False, every OC was an OC before they became an OC.

 

[TheOriginalCane]

Have you tried sending him a private message? That might do the trick.

You can't trick @Cribby that easily...

 

[Kamelion4291]

Are you referring to Dorsey? It's insane to want a proven OC rather than a complete unknown? You know who else was a great QB coach, Enos.

It's insane that you think it's insane that people want someone with a proven track record. Many, and I mean many, extremely good position coaches make the jump to coordinator and suck (e.g. Coley). Dorsey could easily suck at installing a scheme, gameplanning, and calling plays. He could be great.

But the bottom line is he's a complete unknown because he's never done it before. I personally would be okay with a Dorsey hire, but given that new coordinators are statistically more likely to fail than to succeed, I'd much prefer someone who has a track record of success and has done it before.

I see you use the term "great" pretty loosely with Enos. His offense wasn't very good when he was the QB coach at Arkansas and he gets a lot of credit for 1 year with Tua, but Tua was starting out better in 2019 than 2018 under Enos.

No matter how much you want to spin it, it's not an equivalent pedigree.

 

[TheOriginalCane]

False, every OC was an OC before they became an OC.

 

[rsa coral gables]

For the record he called two halfback tosses in the snow that game

if the second one had gone for an incompletion, i would not have been surprised if he had called a third.

 

[Kamelion4291]

there is 31 other qb coaches in the nfl. why aren’t you mentioning them as a homerun hire?

Maybe because a guy who coached up one MVP and then a runner MVP who was a mess before he was hired isn't the same as hiring the QB coach of the Jacksonville Jaguars?

You think I give a **** about hiring Dorsey just because he's in the NFL and not because he's been great in the NFL?

The **** kind of question is this?

 

[RedPill Stepdad]

Coaching mahomoes or Brady doesn’t up your stock probably takes away from it.

so coaching mahomes, who was drafted later than both qbs you’re giving dorsey credit for, takes away from your stock? hilarious.

 

[NosniknoT]

I can't even keep track of who is officially announced yet, seems like we get a new assistant everyday confirmed so by next week we may know who the OC and DC is. Was the d line coach an official hire yet? If not that will probably be who is announced today

 

[d--1]

False, every OC was an OC before they became an OC.

Facts

 

[ATL-BRAD]

Not sure what you’re point is but okay.

That is my point of the kids are told it’s a spread it can be anyone

 

[Cribby]

Have you tried sending him a private message? That might do the trick.

I’ve always taken one day to read and respond to PM’s. I’m now drowning lol, I’m not an ******* , I’m just buried. So my apologies to everyone.

 

[TOcane]

False, every OC was an OC before they became an OC.

Don’t know how but we did it. We turned OCs into a chicken or the egg.

 

[RedPill Stepdad]

Maybe because a guy who coached up one MVP and then a runner MVP who was a mess before he was hired isn't the same as hiring the QB coach of the Jacksonville Jaguars?

You think I give a **** about hiring Dorsey just because he's in the NFL and not because he's been great in the NFL?

The **** kind of question is this?

when brady was brought up you all questioned if he called plays at lsu, his willingness to recruit and how long he would be here. those same questions apply to dorsey but yet not a peep. you all care so much about dorsey because he played here, it’s that simple.

 

[TheOriginalCane]

so coaching mahomes, who was drafted later than both qbs you’re giving dorsey credit for, takes away from your stock? hilarious.

He gave multiple examples, not just Mahomes. What he is saying is very simple, it might take away from your stock AS A DEVELOPER OF QBs to coach a particular guy who is already great, or who has always been great. As opposed, say, to a coach to takes a not-great QB, helps him become a great QB, and then maybe that QB becomes not-great again once the coach leaves.

It's a valid point. It doesn't mean that every QB coach that coaches a great QB is not a great coach (thanks, @Canes Legacy ). Just that coaches who can show how they improved particular QBs may get more credit for being DEVELOPERS, which is an important skill at the collegiate level.

 

[RiDLer80]

Don't matter.

What kind of stupid *** post is this? So you want a completely inexperienced QB coach to learn on the job and be in charge of developing our QBs?

 

[TheOriginalCane]

when brady was brought up you all questioned if he called plays at lsu, his willingness to recruit and how long he would be here long. those same questions apply to dorsey but yet not a peep. you all care so much about dorsey because he played here, it’s that simple.

Wrong.

 

[ThomasM]

when brady was brought up you all questioned if he called plays at lsu, his willingness to recruit and how long he would be here long. those same questions apply to dorsey but yet not a peep. you all care so much about dorsey because he played here, it’s that simple.

I don't care that he played here. I am also fine with Brady. But hey, that's just me. I like Dorsey's resume, a lot. His NFL resume, not his college QB resume.