Some insignificant message board ponderings...
#1 Would other Dade coaches be jealous? I'm sure they would all applaud it in public, but in the back of their minds many of the big dogs would be saying "Why him and not me?" Lots of these folks are gigantic egos with a me-me attitude. I wouldn't blame Bennett for being upset if he were passed over.... NFL RB, former Cane, just helped us land Coley.... he has a pretty decent resume for it.
#2 What happens if things don't go well? Whoever we hire won't be here forever. It's possible they could entrench themselves into UM staff forever, but we've been down this road with Ice, and now we have to deal with that ****. If/when Lockett's tenure is up, is it going to be Ice Part 2?
#3 If you're Sony Michel and they hire Cook's coach, do you think you're ever going to be the guy or are you going to be playing second fiddle? This point is so insignificant that it wouldn't factor into my decision at all if I were calling the shots - you have to hire the right guy and can't worry about 1 kid - but it's message board fodder anyway.
There are clearly things to like about him as a potential hire, but I don't think it's the no-brainer that fans are suggesting.