forums

QBS in the Portal as of 11/28

JustAFanHTX said:
I’ll take it light and say the injuries and he needs a change of scenery. I’m really close with the family but he needs a reality check and I think this is it. Talent is there
Click to expand...
I think weigman would be a good fallback option like a miller moss. Tough to have him on top given he was bad this year. Obviously got talent.
 
Advertisement
I said 2 days ago or so Arnold is my guy. With that said I also dont have faith that this is the QB they staff would be willing to bring in and work with.

I would say he probably goes to Ole Miss, Miss State to reunite with Lebby or somewhere in Texas like TCU.

I would rather the risk of Arnold than the "safe-ish" pick with Miller Moss
 
Manfred_Cane said:
We have a top 5(?) offense in the country. If we have a top 10-20 offense in 2025, its technically a step back.

I agree with you though. The next QB whether it's Mateer or Sawyer Robertson or Hoover or Nuss, they can put up numbers in this offense.
Click to expand...
Is it a step back with a top 15 defense, though?
 
JustAFanHTX said:
I’m a really big fan and the talent is there. Also look at his character. Turned into a RB to help his team win.
Click to expand...
You think he's staying 2 years?
If not it may still be better to go another direction. But if you get him 2 years, there probably aren't better options.
 
Advertisement
Cribby said:
I think Arnold is a sneaky good pickup. He’s still young and had a horrible situation. There’s multiple examples of guys like him leaving and being successful. McCord and Nix being a couple.
Click to expand...
Is Dawson here next year? He could get a HC job and thank Cam Ward for that. I think the qb I want depends on the system. If it’s the same system I want Mateer.
 
I think Arnold is less riskier than Mateer. I know he played in same system as Cam, but WSC schedule was not like Cam’s WSC schedules.
 
nycane said:
this. He's electric but he missed open guys like JG and Arroyo a TON. He also dances around and holds the ball too long. He can be sloppy but he's dynamic. I dont see it carrying over in the NFL but im still glad we had him.
Click to expand...
Ward was the best in the biz in the first and fourth quarters.
He was just "average" in quarters 2 and 3, with the 53rd and 36th best passer rating.
The team was a reflection of that.
 
Advertisement
Calinative said:
You think he's staying 2 years?
If not it may still be better to go another direction. But if you get him 2 years, there probably aren't better options.
Click to expand...
Where he going? He would have to stay both years if he wants to be drafted
 
Advertisement
252cane said:
Where he going? He would have to stay both years if he wants to be drafted
Click to expand...
He could declare for the draft... Next season will be his 3rd.
I'm asking if he is a guy that is trying to stay 2 season, or if he's looking for a 1 and done
 
Advertisement
Calinative said:
He could declare for the draft... Next season will be his 3rd.
I'm asking if he is a guy that is trying to stay 2 season, or if he's looking for a 1 and done
Click to expand...
He hasn’t played well enough to be 1 and done he would go undrafted
 
Da Jumbo Mutombo said:
Mateer is in a league of his own. Easily #1.

Arnold and Weigman would have the highest upside and lowest floor. Riskiest.

Moss would bring a higher floor but lower ceiling.

I guess out of the rest, I'd put Arnold first. But not sure how confident I'd be playing ND and UF in fiest 4 weeks next season with him as QB.
Click to expand...
Not bad, I'd probably switch Arnold and moss in a one year window.
Did Arnold play full game against bama. Thought so.
 
You guys are getting me excited about this Arnold kid which probably means he goes elsewhere lol. I like the comparison to Bo Nix assuming his skill set fits what SD likes to do.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top