Daily debate: what QB would you want over Carson Beck?

[cway313]

....= overrated

Probably, but I like family legacies.

 

[CANESCANES]

I was wearing a Miami shirt at Dollywood Saturday and these guys from Georgia asked if I was excited about Beck because they said I shouldn't be. I said he's better than what Miami currently had after Ward.

UGA fans are already *****ing about Stockton not being good enough, and Kirby playing him over the other guys

 

[JHallCanes]

Mateer
Manning


Cant think of any others till they emerge. And when you think about it, it is a tough question. It was tough to take Beck over DJU and the gnome at FSU, I almost included their names.

I’m gassing up the “no excuses” bus as we speak

 

[Ghurd8]

You should look at his numbers. He was a top 5 QB last year.

Yes

He reminds me of Kenny Pickett. Good player at the end but the ceiling is clear to me. If he follows up last year with similar or better he might even get drafted in a similar spot.

 

[NC_Canes_11]

He reminds me of Kenny Pickett. Good player at the end but the ceiling is clear to me. If he follows up last year with similar or better he might even get drafted in a similar spot.

Not a bad comparison.

But Idc what his draft stock is. This isn’t an NFL board. He’s turned into a really good college QB. And right now he’s better than Beck

 

[Brooklyndee]

For sure - Klubnik, Leavitt, Mateer

Maybe (depends on Beck’s recovery) - Nuss, Arch

You'd take cade klubneck over Carson beck? Ok.

 

[Brooklyndee]

You should look at his numbers. He was a top 5 QB last year.

Yes

Numbers as we've all seen over and over and over don't tell a full story. While I'll agree he had a nice year last year overall I think it's lunacy to even put him in the same category. Most Clemson fans didnt even want him themselves and plenty still complain about him. So it's not just us. Apparently we're better off with multiple unproven QBs simply off of hype.

 

[NC_Canes_11]

Numbers as we've all seen over and over and over don't tell a full story. While I'll agree he had a nice year last year overall I think it's lunacy to even put him in the same category. Most Clemson fans didnt even want him themselves and plenty still complain about him. So it's not just us. Apparently we're better off with multiple unproven QBs simply off of hype.

Beck had 2 first round weapons catching passes and elite RB’s behind him when he was good. When they left, he wasn’t as good as Klubnik.

 

[AlexCane]

For sure - Klubnik, Leavitt, Mateer

Maybe (depends on Beck’s recovery) - Nuss, Arch

For sure Klubnik? Uh, no. He doesn’t throw passes beyond 5 yards and is handheld by that staff to not overdo things.

Also, one guy was listed as the #1 QB headed into last year on NFL mock drafts and the other is Klubnik.

 

[DC3]

Nuss, Sellers, Arch.

Maybe Klubnik or Allar but they are on the same tier as Beck personally.

 

[AlexCane]

Man I’m losing my mind. We’re talking about Cade Klubnik that lost in an actual, real life football game to Emory Williams being better than Beck? WTF.

 

[Fart Keyhole]

If Beck makes a full recovery, then he's #1.

 

[Memnon]

- Garrett Nussmeier
- Josh Hoover
- Behren Morton
- John Mateer
- Chandler Morris
- Sawyer Robertson
- Rocco Bect
- Dylan Raiola
- Owen McCown

 

[ST26]

- Garrett Nussmeier
- Josh Hoover
- Behren Morton
- John Mateer
- Chandler Morris
- Sawyer Robertson
- Rocco Bect
- Dylan Raiola
- Owen McCown

Ultimate rage bait right there. This is funny

 

[Memnon]

Ultimate rage bait right there. This is funny

No rage bait at all, that's exactly who I would take ahead of Beck.

 

[ST26]

Nuss, Sellers, Arch.

Maybe Klubnik or Allar but they are on the same tier as Beck personally.

Aller and Sellers? That has to be joke.

 

[ST26]

No rage bait at all, that's exactly who I would take ahead of Beck.

One of the worst takes I’ve seen in a while. But you do you man

 

[TheEye]

DJ Lagaway

 

[Memnon]

One of the worst takes I’ve seen in a while. But you do you man

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

 

[JHallCanes]

- Garrett Nussmeier
- Josh Hoover
- Behren Morton
- John Mateer
- Chandler Morris
- Sawyer Robertson
- Rocco Bect
- Dylan Raiola
- Owen McCown

Ngl Sawyer Robinson is just a take on name alone