Here is me on Walton in March 2018:
Bruh why are you seriously comparing Mark Waltons production to Duke Johnsons though? lol, its honestly kinda ridiculous because Duke is the BEST rb in our history, statistically. Also you're arguing with me over it, who was NOT one of the people claiming Mark Walton was going to be some elite...
www.canesinsight.com
On par with Duke is a different animal than on par with a Top 10 overall pick. The only reason McCaffrey's name even came up was because pass-catching was a big part of his profile, like Duke, White and Walton. But the actual comparisons of role were always to Duke and James White.
Walton was well on his way there before getting in trouble. Projecting his four starts over 16 games, you have 912 yards from scrimmage which is an average Duke season. But of course, projection is not production so it's all a "what if."