We have ourselves to blame of course, but that doesn't mean the committee's rankings are justified.
I shared a little info from a trusted source about the committee’s dilemma, along w/ the case for & against both programs.
My guy said “his gut” feel would be we would edge out Bama purely based on optics & backlash that may come, but Warde Manuel chose the S.O.S & nerd stats as opposed the 10 wins v. 9 win argument.
The fact is if we beat Cuse, we’re in regardless. We left this up to interpretation, and losing 2/3 to end the season to two unranked teams put us under a bigger microscope. To be blunt, I likened this to the kneel situation last season. Take care of business, & this is a not even a discussion; but, since it’s become a discussion:
It boiled down to this:
Miami opponent’s record: 74-70 (.514 win%)
Bama opponent’s record: 92-52 (.639 win%)
Miami’s conference opponent’s record: 51-45 (.531)
Bama’s conference opponent’s record: 63-33 (.656)
Miami’s quality wins: 0
Bama’s quality wins: 3
So yes, while Bama did lose 2 bad games, it also hurt that we limped down our schedule during ACC play. The ? became if Miami is struggling against inferior opponents, what will happen in the CFP? Albeit Bama lost to 2 bad conference opponents, Bama had also proven to be able to compete & beat current CFP ranked teams. So it wasn’t just us losing 2/3 to end the season, it was also that we struggled against non CFP ranked teams, & truthfully, I heard some felt we were lucky to be a 10 win team. We got the FSU treatment based upon how FSU looked w/o Travis, they saw we weren’t the same Miami pre-ACC play.
This was literally just told to me; hence, y I had a DM telling my peoples I know we don’t believe in the whole “ACC, ACC” bull ****, but we really need to start rooting for VA Tech, Cal, & UL just in case November bites us in the *** again, b/c if it comes to splitting hairs, the committee is going to choose S.O.S if we stumble & don’t make it to the ACCCG.
I don’t agree w/ it, but u never leave in the hands of others. This is legit fumbling the bag.