It is what it is. Miramar/Pembroke Pines is a suburb of miami. Its where folks from Liberty City/Carol City migrated to like my family did.
And Hallandale...Carver Ranches definately claim it like that as Broward. Because they are a bit different as Miramar and Pembroke are newer cities. Folks grand and great grandparents grew up in Carver Ranches or on Foster road...majority of people...Moved to Miramar/Pembroke from dade. I personally rep BROWARD n Dade.
Most of the Carver Ranches, Hallandale, Liberia/Hollywood, Dania folks rep Broward because they're moving around from one to the other often. Those neighborhoods have a lot of connections. Those are very old communities. Like the black ones in Fort Lauderdale and Pompano.
They are all black communities started when people were working on the old Flagler railroad or farming near it. That's why so many of those communities are between 95 and the railroad. Flagler, Model Land Company and other employers wanted black workers living as near to work as possible. My family has been in Dania/Liberia for over 100 years.
Before integration, the black folk from all those neighborhoods (and even black neighborhoods as far south as Ojus, which is near present-day Aventura) I just mentioned went to Attucks High in Liberia. So they have ties to each other as Broward residents and as older neighborhoods.
The Miramars and Pembroke Pines, and others of Southwest Broward, as Gogeta4 stated, are younger communities, often comprised, as Carol City was, of people who moved from Overtown and Liberty City areas of Miami usually from projects or apartments to single-family homes. So they have more of a tie to Dade.
I grew up in Dania. Played football for Northeast in Liberia. Played basketball for Washington Park in Carver Ranches. And hung out with family in the black part of Hallandale. I also went to school in Miami for a time at Bunche Park in Opa Locka. Never considered myself from Dade even though it was that close. Broward all the way.
I think of black Broward as 4 distinct groups.
- Southwest Broward (Miramar, Pines, etc)
- South Broward (Carver Ranches, Hallandale, Liberia, Dania)
- Fort Lauderdale (Sistrunk area, Lauderhill, over by Fort Lauderdale HS, all the stuff near the Swap Shop, by Piper and Boyd Anderson, etc.)
- North Broward (Deerfield and Pompano).
Of the 4, the only one that would make sense to rep Dade county is Southwest Broward. The other three really have few ties to Dade county. They're their own separate things. Even from each other to a certain extent. Somebody in Miramar prolly has no lived experience in Pompano.
Gotta remember, Dade, Broward and Palm Beach, even before the population surge of the last few decades, are three BIG *** COUNTIES. lol