- Joined
- Sep 4, 2012
- Messages
- 43,263
Nobody is saying Rumph can't coach. I think he can.
But to say he's better than Smart right now? Laughable.
He shouldn't be. And I'm sure he wouldn't even tell you that he is.
There's no substitute for the experience and tutelage that Smart has gotten over the years. If ANYBODY ELSE had the resume yall would be crowning him. If we hired a Nick Saban disciple tomorrow this board would go ape **** talkin' about "This guy learned DB's under Saban for 10 years mannnn!"
nah... I'm saying you can't tell who's a better coach based on a resume.
And I'm saying I've heard both of them speak about defense/DB's. And they're not on the same level right now.
We talking about coaching or public speaking?
WTF does public speaking have to do with anything?
You think you can't get a gauge on a guy's knowledge or coaching ability by talking to them (or watching them clinic) for a couple hours?
I sure as **** can.
You're the same guy who gauged Doritos as a coaching genius after he sat down with you for a half hour and went over film.