What did you see in Emory that made you think he’s a starter at a P5 program?
when i saw him throw at one of the elite 11’s
his accuracy is top tier as a thrower.
His size and build
his mental makeup and approach
He has all the tools as a thrower, he just needs to learn how to be a QB.
I am also going not just on my observations, but those opinions of people i trust that have also seem him play
And throw out the struggles in his two games he started this year.
Ken Dorsey was 4 for 12 and 7 of 16 in his first two games. (NOT saying he’s Dorsey).
But the point is, QB eval and development process is a very much “big picture” exercise. Don’t know if Emory definitely delivers. Too early to tell. And at this point, no one else does. But the tools are there to say he has a chance and that’s all you can ask or expect. And to make a determination based on what we know today that he’s not it, is pretty silly and no good coach would do that
I knew Jake Garcia was going to suck from the jump because I saw obvious deficiencies that coaching couldn’t overcome. But I also thought that TVD’s arm talent was going to carry him further and more consistently than it did. The evidence was there from the start for both, just as it is for emory to be good.
Am I wrong or right? Who the fu*k knows …. But my observation is I think emory’s got a good shot. After staying healthy, the most important thing is that he has the mental makeup for a good QB. I’ve worked with QB’s who had mediocre arm strength and made them better. i have also helped guys with footwork issues, or ball handling challenges.
But neither I nor any coach can fix stupid.
And you can’t make a kid tougher and more motivated of they aren’t already wired that way.
But with kids like Emory, when you got smart, tough, and motivated, and you throw in big and strong, you got a chance to mould them into a player.
After that: The rest is mostly just good fortune