Kaaya staying IMO

[canesupremacy]

So he just got his grade back & he got a grade of low fifth round. He's not the type that will impress at combines either. Not really a physical specimen so he pretty much knows his grade. Knowing Angela I can't see her supporting a decision to leave now & brad is every bit as mama's boy. Considering that & our schedule next year I'd have to guess (emphasize I'm guessing here)that he'll be back. With him here next year & oline tightened up well be in the playoffs period.

Total BS post. Don't be sheep people.

The ratings system was revised as well. In previous years, the Committee would evaluate players in one of five categories: potential first-round pick, potential second-round pick, potential third-round pick, no potential for the first three rounds or no draft potential at all. The new ratings are much simpler: potential first round, potential second round, or neither, which is effectively a recommendation to stay in school.

Lol. When did he say he got it from the advisory board? If you make a big decision based on one opinion then you are a fool. There are other qualified people to get advise from.

 

[Bunker Mentality]

Agree 100% with Lu's post. However, if we all agree pocket presence and the ability to throw with the rush baring down is his big area of needed improvement (since he's not going to just get more "athletic" over night) how can BK improve that? Curious for answer on the former since the latter really will be proven when he gets hit in the mouth (and that doesn't happen in practice).

The long & the short of it is what was his problem from jump. He needs to see significant improvement next year from the oline. On the other hand it is significant that we have a weak schedule & he'll have another year to work with someone widely considered a qb guru in Richt. This should be a simple decision.

He's good enough to be drafted by round 3 in a draft short on QBs, with teams thirsty for new talent. Someone will pick him and sit him for a year or two.

 

[rmcid]

Love the jnfo from Brooklyn but but you white knights are driving me crazy. Man doesn't need the defenders. And he should own up that his post said he got his grade - singular - as in suggesting it's the grade from the advisory committee. No big deal and quickly cleared up. He got back some evaluations from a few sources and the consensus put him in the late fifth as a grade. Coupled with the advisory committee not grading him in the first two rounds, it should help persuade him to stay.

 

[UMFarArcher]

I was under the assumption that your NFL draft grade was that you're either in the 1st or 2nd round, or nothing at all.

That's why I immediately smelled BS.

 

[Notsince1985]

If he comes back Rozier transfers Probably Sherrif also.

Why is that downvoted? It's almost certainly true. I think either way they both eventually transfer. Just probably not at the same time. The next starter will be a freshman whether it's allison or Perry.

A QB roster of Kaaya, Allison, Testaverde and Perry (likely red-shirting?) is a good thing, I don't know why that got down voted either. It's a likely outcome.

It's not a question of whether or not Kaaya is the best QB in D1, etc. It's that he gives us the best chance to win. No one behind him has had any meaningful burn this year.

Do not sleep on this kid

View attachment 41180

Yeah, he'll be more ready than most Freshman considering his dad was a QB, Coached by Richt, and Heisman runner-up. He's gonna be tough to beat out. I'm sure he's already got the offense and the footwork down. His dad could be a QB coach for Richt.

hmmm.......

 

[Ajax]

I'm not sure staying another year is going to help him with the deficiencies that he has. He's not going to get much more mobile.

This offense we run is not well suited for him either. 1 of the 3 options in the RPO (QB Run) is basically a non-existent threat to the defense.

That said, hope he stays because he is a good college QB and it gives us another year to develop his successor.

 

[LuCane]

I'm not sure staying another year is going to help him with the deficiencies that he has. He's not going to get much more mobile.

This offense we run is not well suited for him either. 1 of the 3 options in the RPO (QB Run) is basically a non-existent threat to the defense.

That said, hope he stays because he is a good college QB and it gives us another year to develop his successor.

Whether he likes it or not, putting it on film will play a part in his draft stock. He's not going to get faster or start breaking runs, but if he wants any kind of success in the NFL - even if that means sticking around as a legitimate backup - he'll have to show he can slide in and around the pocket.

If he leaves, and is fortunate enough to be selected in the 3rd round, he'll have to pick up that skill and show it off while being on the chopping block. That's best case scenario if he leaves early. If he stays, he has a year to put it on film, potentially jump into the 2nd round and more guaranteed money, while getting more leeway from an NFL team than a 3rd-5th rounder would. A lot of it depends on where he'd eventually go this year, obviously.
2nd round is a sound decision.
3rd round is questionable to leave but not terrible.
4th or 5th round is an outright bad decision.

What he's told before the draft is one thing. It's still a risk on his part.

 

[CaniacMike21]

I was under the assumption that your NFL draft grade was that you're either in the 1st or 2nd round, or nothing at all.

It is. This guy is completely full of ****.

 

[BeastMode]

What's taking Kaaya so long? Every other Junior declaring pretty much does it right after their bowl game.

 

[Cane Dynasty]

So he just got his grade back & he got a grade of low fifth round. He's not the type that will impress at combines either. Not really a physical specimen so he pretty much knows his grade. Knowing Angela I can't see her supporting a decision to leave now & brad is every bit as mama's boy. Considering that & our schedule next year I'd have to guess (emphasize I'm guessing here)that he'll be back. With him here next year & oline tightened up well be in the playoffs period.

When are they gonna open up the playbook?

Are they waiting to surprise Manny in spring ball?

You're absolutely right. Next year maybe we'll average 70 to appease you. You voted for Trump didn't you...

Yep... I like really like Cane Dynasty but voting wisely isn't his strongest point.

Aside from the fact that the old hag was a terrible candidate that rightly should be kept as far away from the White House as possible, if your kids were doing what my daughter is doing you'd have voted for Trump twice.

 

[Angry Ibis]

I'm not sure staying another year is going to help him with the deficiencies that he has. He's not going to get much more mobile.

This offense we run is not well suited for him either. 1 of the 3 options in the RPO (QB Run) is basically a non-existent threat to the defense.

That said, hope he stays because he is a good college QB and it gives us another year to develop his successor.

Whether he likes it or not, putting it on film will play a part in his draft stock. He's not going to get faster or start breaking runs, but if he wants any kind of success in the NFL - even if that means sticking around as a legitimate backup - he'll have to show he can slide in and around the pocket.

If he leaves, and is fortunate enough to be selected in the 3rd round, he'll have to pick up that skill and show it off while being on the chopping block. That's best case scenario if he leaves early. If he stays, he has a year to put it on film, potentially jump into the 2nd round and more guaranteed money, while getting more leeway from an NFL team than a 3rd-5th rounder would. A lot of it depends on where he'd eventually go this year, obviously.
2nd round is a sound decision.
3rd round is questionable to leave but not terrible.
4th or 5th round is an outright bad decision.

What he's told before the draft is one thing. It's still a risk on his part.

More important to me is what it means for Miami. If he can't do anything to improve, then are we sitting in the same boat we were this year with either a very good QB or a terrible one at the helm depending on if he creates pressure in his head?

 

[AllbouttheU]

I was under the assumption that your NFL draft grade was that you're either in the 1st or 2nd round, or nothing at all.

You are correct which is why the OP is full of ****. The draft committee only gives those two grades. I know that for a fact. Been following the draft for long enough.

I'm sure the draft advisory board isn't the only place Kaaya got opinions from.

OP makes it sound like its from the draft advisory board though.

I'm just curious cause I've been attempting to understand the logic people on here have,but how did I "make it sound like it came from the draft advisory board"? I'm pretty sure all I told yall is he got his grade back & what it was.

Lol you can spin it however you want but when someone hears "draft grade" they are thinking of the advisory board.

 

[LuCane]

I'm not sure staying another year is going to help him with the deficiencies that he has. He's not going to get much more mobile.

This offense we run is not well suited for him either. 1 of the 3 options in the RPO (QB Run) is basically a non-existent threat to the defense.

That said, hope he stays because he is a good college QB and it gives us another year to develop his successor.

Whether he likes it or not, putting it on film will play a part in his draft stock. He's not going to get faster or start breaking runs, but if he wants any kind of success in the NFL - even if that means sticking around as a legitimate backup - he'll have to show he can slide in and around the pocket.

If he leaves, and is fortunate enough to be selected in the 3rd round, he'll have to pick up that skill and show it off while being on the chopping block. That's best case scenario if he leaves early. If he stays, he has a year to put it on film, potentially jump into the 2nd round and more guaranteed money, while getting more leeway from an NFL team than a 3rd-5th rounder would. A lot of it depends on where he'd eventually go this year, obviously.
2nd round is a sound decision.
3rd round is questionable to leave but not terrible.
4th or 5th round is an outright bad decision.

What he's told before the draft is one thing. It's still a risk on his part.

More important to me is what it means for Miami. If he can't do anything to improve, then are we sitting in the same boat we were this year with either a very good QB or a terrible one at the helm depending on if he creates pressure in his head?

I think he'd be our best option next year. I have no real idea if the guy stays or goes, but I think it'd mutually beneficial for both sides. Of course, as others have mentioned to me (I'm in no way connected to Kaaya), you never know what goes into someone's reasoning.

 

[Gables Cane]

IMHO...He gone. Relationships prevail over draft grade.

Hope I'm wrong. He gives us the best chance of winning next year.

 

[tcgrad1014]

What's taking Kaaya so long? Every other Junior declaring pretty much does it right after their bowl game.

Probably because his decision is not an easy one. A guy like Dalvin Cook didn't have anything to think about.

 

[brock]

If kaaya comes back he needs to get to the 225-230 range putting some more muscle on

 

[itsacanething]

IMHO...He gone. Relationships prevail over draft grade.

Hope I'm wrong. He gives us the best chance of winning next year.

He is waiting a long time to decide. Cook already announced. Must be legitimately torn or still gathering information.

 

[Brooklyndee]

So he just got his grade back & he got a grade of low fifth round. He's not the type that will impress at combines either. Not really a physical specimen so he pretty much knows his grade. Knowing Angela I can't see her supporting a decision to leave now & brad is every bit as mama's boy. Considering that & our schedule next year I'd have to guess (emphasize I'm guessing here)that he'll be back. With him here next year & oline tightened up well be in the playoffs period.

Total BS post. Don't be sheep people.

The ratings system was revised as well. In previous years, the Committee would evaluate players in one of five categories: potential first-round pick, potential second-round pick, potential third-round pick, no potential for the first three rounds or no draft potential at all. The new ratings are much simpler: potential first round, potential second round, or neither, which is effectively a recommendation to stay in school.

You seem to be rather articulate which would imply you understand linguistics yet your sheer lack of reading comprehension shows that to be a farce... I had such hopes for you. I'm always confused why people like to comment if the clearly don't bother to read the thread. Seems foolish to comment about something covered over & over... but hey maybe that's just me.

 

[BigCaneAl]

I'm not sure staying another year is going to help him with the deficiencies that he has. He's not going to get much more mobile.

This offense we run is not well suited for him either. 1 of the 3 options in the RPO (QB Run) is basically a non-existent threat to the defense.

That said, hope he stays because he is a good college QB and it gives us another year to develop his successor.

Whether he likes it or not, putting it on film will play a part in his draft stock. He's not going to get faster or start breaking runs, but if he wants any kind of success in the NFL - even if that means sticking around as a legitimate backup - he'll have to show he can slide in and around the pocket.

If he leaves, and is fortunate enough to be selected in the 3rd round, he'll have to pick up that skill and show it off while being on the chopping block. That's best case scenario if he leaves early. If he stays, he has a year to put it on film, potentially jump into the 2nd round and more guaranteed money, while getting more leeway from an NFL team than a 3rd-5th rounder would. A lot of it depends on where he'd eventually go this year, obviously.
2nd round is a sound decision.
3rd round is questionable to leave but not terrible.
4th or 5th round is an outright bad decision.

What he's told before the draft is one thing. It's still a risk on his part.

More important to me is what it means for Miami. If he can't do anything to improve, then are we sitting in the same boat we were this year with either a very good QB or a terrible one at the helm depending on if he creates pressure in his head?

I think he'd be our best option next year. I have no real idea if the guy stays or goes, but I think it'd mutually beneficial for both sides. Of course, as others have mentioned to me (I'm in no way connected to Kaaya), you never know what goes into someone's reasoning.

I sort of disagree here....I think we know what we are getting with Kaaya. Can he win 10 games next year, yes...can he take us to the playoffs, no. I don't think he's athletic enough, with our o-line, to beat elite defenses. I'm not sure if Allison would, but at least I am not sure he can't.

IMHO the question is are you good with 9-10 wins, or do you want to go with the higher risk higher potential reward and roll with Perry or Allison.

 

[Brooklyndee]

Love the jnfo from Brooklyn but but you white knights are driving me crazy. Man doesn't need the defenders. And he should own up that his post said he got his grade - singular - as in suggesting it's the grade from the advisory committee. No big deal and quickly cleared up. He got back some evaluations from a few sources and the consensus put him in the late fifth as a grade. Coupled with the advisory committee not grading him in the first two rounds, it should help persuade him to stay.

Actually I have nothing to own up to as nothing at all was implied other that what was stated. A football prospect understandso the advisory committee is certainly not the best way to get a read on things when they have access to a direct source. Lastly I have explained this is sufficient detail in two separate posts that were deleted by mods or whomever that has such authority. I have no problem with that though because my frustration leads me to explain things that the majority should have no access to. If you like an example just look for the post by a mod which explains clearly we definitely don't make any direct contact with agents or any one affiliated to agents as that is illegal for both parties. Thanks though.