Jelani is best suited as a strong side 4-3 IMO. But yes he can bulk up and be a solid 3-4.
That being said a great defensive line doesn't only need one or two impact guys but a bunch of quality depth as well.
Enough with all this developement stuff. How many these guys to you think are really going to develop into something above average to special? And even then the good ones always show flashes instantly.
You could see Jelani's burst this past year with as little as he played. Who else on the squad shows that kind size/strength ratio with quick twitch explosion off the line to play the interior? Plus there are guys like Marvin Austin that ball from the get go.
Who's going to man the nose then Porter is gone. The nose(3 technique) is the absolutely most important position for this style of defense. Ivery? Corey King?
And what does any of that have to do with Golden's inability to pull in young studs last cycle and this one up to now?
If we have to wait til next year for a couple of impact making interior linemen and if they need 2 years to develope what is that going to say about our defense in the next couple of years even with all the young LB and DB talent we have?
I suspect it will be either Ivery, Moore or Bryant (if he comes aboard).
Your comment re: "enough with development" is tough to understand. There are countless examples of Frosh interior linemen who developed over a few (meaning 2-3) seasons.
Let's take a look:
2012 NFL Draft
Dontari Poe - #11 Overall (1st Round) - 2star prospect by Rivals and Scout.com; REDSHIRTED his first year; only got 6 starts in his RS Frosh year, which was his second year in college; 27 tackles total that year; became a consistent starter his 3rd year in college.
Fletcher Cox - #12 Overall (1st Round) - DEFENSIVE END coming out of HS; played in 12 games as a true frosh, but only started in 4 games; started 11 games as a Sophomore, before leaving as a Junior.
Derrick Wolfe - #36 overall (2nd Round) - 2 star recruit by Rivals.com; 0 starts as a freshman; played as a backup in half the games; made 13 starts as a sophomore; put it all together as a Senior to be the co-big east defensive player of the year.
Kendall Reyes - #49 overall (2nd Round) - Played defensive End in high school; 6' 4" 220 pound recruit; 2 star recruit on scout; REDSHIRTED; started in 4 games as a RS Frosh (2nd year of college); took hold of a DT position and started 12 games as a RS Sophomore (3rd year on college), ala William Joseph; put it all together as a junior, in 2010, and was a first team all-conference player.
Jerel Worthy - #51 overall (2nd Round) - 2 star recruit on Scout.com and 78th best defensive tackle as a HS recruit; REDSHIRTED; started 11 games as a RS Frosh (2nd year of college); put it all together in his third year of college, starting 13 games and earning some All-American honors.
Devon Still - #53 overall (2nd Round) - 4 star recruit on Scout.com; REDSHIRTED; tore his knee his second year; debut was in 2008 (his 3rd year in college); put it all together as a 5th year senior, where he started 12 games and made all-conference.
You're a smart guy, so you can add all that up and discuss reasonably. Those are the DTs selected in the first 2 rounds of the last NFL draft:
- 4 of 6 took redshirts
- earliest impact was made in 2nd year of college
- 4 of 6 were 2 star recruits
Development of interior DLinemen is the name of the game.