Kn[]_[]ckles3o5;1458036 said:
Not disagreeing that Saban has more years under his belt. One thing I will point out is that he doesn't necessarily have a reputation for being a great gameday coach either. Even with all of his experience. I think he gets the nod for team building and preparation, not so much for in game adjustments and schemes. He operates on the premise that other teams will have to stop him from doing what he wants to do. I mean let's be honest his approach to the game is not terribly complicated. If he were to get any credit for his Xs and Os I guess it would be in the secondary, beyond that it's just a bully mentality. I'm bigger and stronger and you have to figure out how to stop me.
For the record I don't think Golden's, or any other great coach's, approach is far off of that. Save the idea that Golden likes a bit flashier offense and he knows at Miami he can get those players. Titles or not Alabama (the state) isn't producing the pieces needed to play offense like the notoriously explosive teams in the country like Miami, USC, Oklahoma, and Oregon. Bama plays a smash mouth style and they just need the one guy on the outside that can get down the field. Cooper does that for them but, they aren't gonna be setting any passing records in Tuscaloosa anytime soon.
Saban's genius is in having his team playing at a high level mentally every fugging week. He doesn't allow them to sag like other corches do and get beat when they shouldn't. His team is full of 4 and 5 stars who play at 4 and 5 star levels because he has them mentally prepared every week.
There aren't many HCs who are reinventing football at this point. Every good coach knows all the plays and formations and all that ****. They all know the same stuff.
There are a select few who are renowned as gameday geniuses for their strategic moves, and that's usually all hype. Belichick used to be a guy like that (suddenly not so smart) and
so was Joe Gibbs his first time around (notice how he got dumb the 2nd stint with the Skins though). A lot of that coaching gameday genius **** is overblown by fans and media nerds looking to create superheroes out of coaches.
The great HCs do one thing better than the others on gameday, and that's having their troops playing at a very high emotional/mental level. The great HCs, like Saban, are great leaders of men and great button pushers. They're not guys sitting in a lab with beekers and microscopes and white smoks concocting some other worldly plan that no one has ever seen. Good football guys have seen everything at this point. HCs aren't even involved in all that **** anyway. That's what their coordinators are for--putting together gameplans and making calls while the bullets are flying.