forums

Daily debate: what QB would you want over Carson Beck?

JHallCanes

JHallCanes

2028 is our year
Premium
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
48,594
Not a gotcha question just genuinely curious

Opinions on Beck seem to be pretty mixed. I think part of it is just coming back to earth after Cam but also knowing Beck is coming off of a major injury

Perfect world who would you want as Miami’s QB for 2025 over Carson Beck?

I had a tougher time with this question than I thought so figured I’d put it out there
 

Advertisement
College Football Celebration GIF by SEC Network
 
Advertisement
JHallCanes said:
Not a gotcha question just genuinely curious

Opinions on Beck seem to be pretty mixed. I think part of it is just coming back to earth after Cam but also knowing Beck is coming off of a major injury

Perfect world who would you want as Miami’s QB for 2025 over Carson Beck?

I had a tougher time with this question than I thought so figured I’d put it out there
Click to expand...
Id go with John Mateer, since he has 2 years of eligibility left

I’m good with Carson Beck, glad he’s at Miami, love his talent

Grok predicted Carson Beck 2025 season to be :


IMG_5547.jpeg
 
Advertisement
Brooklyndee said:
This is yet another cis special. Let's start dialogue about the many QBs we would rather have opposed to the one we do have who's won multiple sec and national championships... Fml. Gotta love this place.
woody harrelson drinking GIF
Click to expand...
The national championships were won with him on the sideline. He lost 1 SEC championship game and the backup Stockton won the other. He never won anything as the starter.
 
Brooklyndee said:
This is yet another cis special. Let's start dialogue about the many QBs we would rather have opposed to the one we do have who's won multiple sec and national championships... Fml. Gotta love this place.
woody harrelson drinking GIF
Click to expand...
Not that it matters to me if you think that, but no that’s not me

I’ve read enough Beck negatives here to be genuinely curious who would be a better option

I can’t think of any myself so I was hoping to hear those that are down on him give some better options

Seems to me between him and Nickel we actually are sitting pretty good at QB compared to the rest of the country
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Brooklyndee said:
This is yet another cis special. Let's start dialogue about the many QBs we would rather have opposed to the one we do have who's won multiple sec and national championships... Fml. Gotta love this place.
woody harrelson drinking GIF
Click to expand...
I was wearing a Miami shirt at Dollywood Saturday and these guys from Georgia asked if I was excited about Beck because they said I shouldn't be. I said he's better than what Miami currently had after Ward.
 
Brooklyndee said:
This is yet another cis special. Let's start dialogue about the many QBs we would rather have opposed to the one we do have who's won multiple sec and national championships... Fml. Gotta love this place.
woody harrelson drinking GIF
Click to expand...

I'm not sure what you are trying to say regarding starting a dialogue. The purpose of the thread was to mention names we would potentially like over Beck. I'm saying Beck is the most proven QB coming back this year. That doesn't necessarily mean he will be the best. Arch is obvious and Mateer is intriguing due to his running ability. Both are somewhat unproven but I think most will say they are going to be good. Beck could also end up being the best. Time will tell.
 
Advertisement
canes_aaron said:
I'm not sure what you are trying to say regarding starting a dialogue. The purpose of the thread was to mention names we would potentially like over Beck. I'm saying Beck is the most proven QB coming back this year. That doesn't necessarily mean he will be the best. Arch is obvious and Mateer is intriguing due to his running ability. Both are somewhat unproven but I think most will say they are going to be good. Beck could also end up being the best.Time will tell.
Click to expand...
You get it

It’s a layered topic. I’m not saying any criticisms of Beck are off limits because he’s one of the best options

Also not saying Beck is a bum and I just want to wish we had someone else

I’m looking around CFB and then looking ahead to the draft and it’s a big question mark

As it relates to us I don’t see any reason why the playoff standard for Mario should be off the table but others might disagree
 
Brooklyndee said:
This is yet another cis special. Let's start dialogue about the many QBs we would rather have opposed to the one we do have who's won multiple sec and national championships... Fml. Gotta love this place.
woody harrelson drinking GIF
Click to expand...
Not saying this particular thread is ****ting on Beck but CIS Wouldn't be CIS w/o drooling over other teams unproven players while ****ting on our own, common practice here.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top