forums

Carson Beck

Hufftwoseven said:
Rank these QB’s in order you would want them starting for Miami next year

Carson Beck
Quinn Ewers
Jalen Milroe
Emory Williams
Rocco Becht
Avery Johnson
Emory Williams
Kyron Drones
Click to expand...
Adding two to your list that aren't in the portal:

1. Sam Leavitt
2. Sawyer Robertson
3. Quinn Ewers
4. Jalen Milroe
5. Rocco Becht
6. Carson Beck
7. Avery Johnson
8. Kyron Drones
9. Emory Williams
 
Advertisement
Da Jumbo Mutombo said:
Adding two to your list that aren't in the portal:

1. Sam Leavitt
2. Sawyer Robertson
3. Quinn Ewers
4. Jalen Milroe
5. Rocco Becht
6. Carson Beck
7. Avery Johnson
8. Kyron Drones
9. Emory Williams
Click to expand...
No way Leavitt leaves ASU, imo. Dillingham is on fire this year with that offense. They been killing it in the portal and recruiting lately. I've seen him play 2x in person and kid is a stud.
 
I’m trying to figure out why there’s so many fans out there who are dead-set against this. He’s been a very good college QB in the SEC, playing in a conservative offense with lackluster WR play and lack of depth at RB this year. The part that nobody is looking at is how much the needle would move nationally if he came here. Portal transfers would be lining up to come here if he announced tomorrow he was transferring to Miami. At Miami, he’d have a better O-Line, better RB’s, better WR room even with the losses, and a better OC. I’m all for this.
 
Advertisement
DoctorKrazey said:
I’m trying to figure out why there’s so many fans out there who are dead-set against this. He’s been a very good college QB in the SEC, playing in a conservative offense with lackluster WR play and lack of depth at RB this year. The part that nobody is looking at is how much the needle would move nationally if he came here. Portal transfers would be lining up to come here if he announced tomorrow he was transferring to Miami. At Miami, he’d have a better O-Line, better RB’s, better WR room even with the losses, and a better OC. I’m all for this.
Click to expand...

So we’re basically better than the SEC champions and playing for Pop Tarts?
 
Angry Ibis said:
So we’re basically better than the SEC champions and playing for Pop Tarts?
Click to expand...
No, obviously our defense is hot garbage compared to Georgia which is what held us back this year. If a QB is looking to raise his draft stock though, they could care less how good or bad the defense is. We had one of the worst defenses in CFB and Cam is still projected as a top five pick. I’m not going to sit here and say I would be as excited about Beck coming here as I was with Ward, but I’m definitely not against it either.
 
Advertisement
I think a lot are missing the point with this Beck vs Emory thing.
For me, yes, I would take Beck over Emory.
But, it's the fact that we had better options out there before it came down to this conversation of what-ifs.

We went all in on Mateer, but.... we could've just rolled with trying to get Jackson Arnold or Mensah on board, but now all of the good options are gone and now we are hypothetically saying it's possible it could be Carson Beck, who, IMO, is a TVD on steroids with an injury.
Yes, I would take Beck over Emory, but I'm mad it's now coming down to that possibility, after seeing all the better QB fits for this system already finding homes.
I think most need to look at perspectives rather thinking we actually wasn't Emory over Beck.

I'm mad it came down to this.
 
*****-Wan Kanobi said:
I think a lot are missing the point with this Beck vs Emory thing.
For me, yes, I would take Beck over Emory.
But, it's the fact that we had better options out there before it came down to this conversation of what-ifs.

We went all in on Mateer, but.... we could've just rolled with trying to get Jackson Arnold or Mensah on board, but now all of the good options are gone and now we are hypothetically saying it's possible it could be Carson Beck, who, IMO, is a TVD on steroids with an injury.
Yes, I would take Beck over Emory, but I'm mad it's now coming down to that possibility, after seeing all the better QB fits for this system already finding homes.
I think most need to look at perspectives rather thinking we actually wasn't Emory over Beck.

I'm mad it came down to this.
Click to expand...
We have no idea that arnold or mensah even wanted to play here . We gotta stop assuming every qb in portal wants to play for miami 🤣
 
*****-Wan Kanobi said:
I think a lot are missing the point with this Beck vs Emory thing.
For me, yes, I would take Beck over Emory.
But, it's the fact that we had better options out there before it came down to this conversation of what-ifs.

We went all in on Mateer, but.... we could've just rolled with trying to get Jackson Arnold or Mensah on board, but now all of the good options are gone and now we are hypothetically saying it's possible it could be Carson Beck, who, IMO, is a TVD on steroids with an injury.
Yes, I would take Beck over Emory, but I'm mad it's now coming down to that possibility, after seeing all the better QB fits for this system already finding homes.
I think most need to look at perspectives rather thinking we actually wasn't Emory over Beck.

I'm mad it came down to this.
Click to expand...

We both know we’ll get a QB, and it will almost certainly be “the name I was told weeks ago” 😈
 
Advertisement
Damiencane86 said:
Strictly on offense yes
Click to expand...

This year. I would actually be hopeful, if a QB like Beck saw the 2025 roster and said, let’s fuc and it wasn’t about getting $2 million to do it. Not because I love the Beck option, but because he was about to go in the draft, from a powerhouse and should be smart enough to judge whether 2024 Miami can be duplicated or not.

I’m not sure I buy that we are better than UGA at all the positions he listed.
 
Angry Ibis said:
Why wouldn’t they?

We had the #1 offense, therefore we are the first choice, of course.
Click to expand...
Because not everybody wants to play where you think they wanna play just because you said it.

I have no idea either, but the fact that you think “why wouldn’t they” is ridiculous. It’s not (necessarily) that simple.

Unless of course it’s your goal to always **** on Miami until you reverse and play the other side until you reverse again
 
Advertisement
Ispyin said:
Because not everybody wants to play where you think they wanna play just because you said it.

I have no idea either, but the fact that you think “why wouldn’t they” is ridiculous. It’s not (necessarily) that simple.

Unless of course it’s your goal to always **** on Miami until you reverse and play the other side until you reverse again
Click to expand...

Too much eggnog to miss the sarcasm?

Or too busy worried about receipts.

**** on? The last month was ******. Deal with it.
 
tr1ck said:
We have no idea that arnold or mensah even wanted to play here . We gotta stop assuming every qb in portal wants to play for miami 🤣
Click to expand...
Would def buy in to that line of thinking, but $$$$ showed why that was the case either would have been interested.

Duke gave Mensah a big enough bag with the condition he had to take it right away. Done
Arnold was rumored to follow his OC to Miss St, but Auburn stopped by with a bigger bag and again it over.

I don’t know what goes into our portal strategy, but two things can be true
1. The tweaks to it this year have resulted in more quality
2. We are a level below in terms of $$$ for the elite guys.

I’m not sure why that is, unless we don’t rank the elite portal candidates the same as everyone else (I get that) or we have a “salary cap” guru working the NIL deals and we generally stick to that with only certain exceptions.
 
tr1ck said:
We have no idea that arnold or mensah even wanted to play here . We gotta stop assuming every qb in portal wants to play for miami 🤣
Click to expand...

You need to re-read what I typed out.

READING COMPREHENSION!!!

I said none of that. I said we could've at least tried, now don't nickpick for the sake of arguing yall already know I'm not with that ****, I'm more of a logical person who deals in reality and the reality is, we put all of our eggs in a basket for a QB who pretty much showed us he wasn't interested to begin with, so why didn't we try with those other options? Maybe we wouldn't be having this convo about Beck vs Emory.
 
*****-Wan Kanobi said:
You need to re-read what I typed out.

READING COMPREHENSION!!!

I said none of that. I said we could've at least tried, now don't nickpick for the sake of arguing yall already know I'm not with that ****, I'm more of a logical person who deals in reality and the reality is, we put all of our eggs in a basket for a QB who pretty much showed us he wasn't interested to begin with, so why didn't we try with those other options? Maybe we wouldn't be having this convo about Beck vs Emory.
Click to expand...
idk if the staff would have viewed arnold as enough of an upgrade over emory, who knows maybe they did call mensah's agent and heard it was 4 mill per year over 2 years and we said nevermind.

we went after mateer because he was the best available and a clear upgrade, i don't think we're going after just anyone
 
Advertisement
Back
Top