forums

Carson Beck

KWCOWBOYFAN said:
Has the mystery QB been mentioned yet?
Click to expand...
College Football Go Badgers GIF by Wisconsin Badgers
 
Advertisement
SCarolina Ibis said:
Come on man. This is an absurd take. What is it even based on? Literally no one except members of his fan club, would watch Emory limp noodle the ball 3 yards beyond the los and think he's better thank Beck.

I'm not even trying to call you out. I just can't understand what the "Emory should start" stuff is based on.

Is it because the coaches "like him"? What if that means they like having him in the locker room, but not as a starter? I mean.. They're actively trying to recruit over him for a reason.

@DMoney called him a game manager. @Memnon has repeatedly said he's not the answer.

What is it?
Click to expand...
Beck is a joke
Everytime I've watched him I ask how is he starting at Georgia, answer they don't need a great QB. I don't see anything in him.
I'm not talking about when he was an 18 year old freshman like emery was I'm talking about the past 2 seasons
Now he's injured. Hard pass

Never said emery should start just he might be able to.
You say noodle arm from 2023 games.
He looked more develop this year 15-20 pounds bigger, looked in command don't care about the opponent or stats just the look.
He beat out a guy who threw 30 ads last year for the backup role.

Again he should play close to half Saturday to see where his develop is
 
Advertisement
tdjones34 said:
Beck is a joke
Everytime I've watched him I ask how is he starting at Georgia, answer they don't need a great QB. I don't see anything in him.
I'm not talking about when he was an 18 year old freshman like emery was I'm talking about the past 2 seasons
Now he's injured. Hard pass

Never said emery should start just he might be able to.
You say noodle arm from 2023 games.
He looked more develop this year 15-20 pounds bigger, looked in command don't care about the opponent or stats just the look.
He beat out a guy who threw 30 ads last year for the backup role.

Again he should play close to half Saturday to see where his develop is
Click to expand...
His arm is still a noodle. Look at the completions he had in that game this year and if he had even an average arm those throws go for touchdowns. The receivers had to come back for the ball on each long balls he threw. If he’s our starter next year, get ready for disappointment.
 
Advertisement
NicKane said:
His arm is still a noodle. Look at the completions he had in that game this year and if he had even an average arm those throws go for touchdowns. The receivers had to come back for the ball on each long balls he threw. If he’s our starter next year, get ready for disappointment.
Click to expand...
Well if he sucks we will be the 24 gators
Nickel will get experience and we will be talk of the football headed into 26 with our great prospect qb having experience

Anything but carson Beck
 
Advertisement
DMoney said:
This guy is an NFL draft pick who put up big numbers in the SEC. He’s tall, has a good arm, and can run. Most importantly, he has a ton of experience. Of course he’s better than most college quarterbacks in the country.

If he jumped in the Portal, he would immediately get a huge transfer grade and a ton of calls. I think Cam Ward has distorted our fanbase’s idea of what a good college QB looks like.

Which is why I keep asking: if Beck is trash, who is better in 2025? It should be a long list.
Click to expand...

"has a good arm,"

Had a good arm is more aqurate right now.
Unknown if it comes back
 
Advertisement
WeBallinBoyz said:
You guys know UGA is top 10 in the country in drops and worst in the P4 right?

I mean Beck isn’t the star everyone thought he’d be, but he’s definitely better than Mendoza. Evidenced by the fact that…Mendoza wound up at Indiana, and not UGA.

UGA has also struggled up front this year and their OL isn’t as good as it normally is, plus the running game has been virtually nonexistent.

Also, Beck is coached by Mike Bobo. We all know how bad Mike Bobo is.

Now, if the conundrum is overpay for Beck out of desperation but don’t add quality receiving threats, or spend less on a different QB to add quality around the team…then idk.

In an ideal world, we’re spending everywhere. Beck can definitely get us 9, probably 10 wins. He’s better than Lagway, he’s better than whatever ND trots out (probably Angeli).

Would be the second best or best QB in the conference…
Click to expand...
If Cal had Beck playing QB this year instead of Mendoza they’d probably be winless.
 
3 games w/ 3 pics. Another w/2. Wildly inconsistent, demonstrated in a Brock Berlin-like game at 'Bama (3TD/3INT). Could you get him back in '23 form? Maybe. Not a slam dunk; and then there's the injury...
 
Advertisement
Back
Top