forums

Carson Beck

fincane said:
You actually watched Georgia. Cool. So did alot of other people. And Mike Bobo aint the reason Beck was throwing into double and triple coverage against Florida because they broke out a zone defense.

Cam Ward went up because he didn't have to run for his life and Miami is an upgrade talent wise from Washington State. Carson Beck will be taking a step down. He had the best infrastructure he could ever ask for and played poorly. You guys want to lean on the ACC being bad. Cam didn't even get a chance to win the ACC when Miami didn't play the other two best teams in the league during conference play.

Using Emory to bolster the argument is nonsense. If Miami can tamper with a freshman CB at Wisconsin, Miami can tamper with a younger QB someplace else who would likely be less expensive than Beck and leave more money to improve the roster around that QB.
Click to expand...
Great, who is the younger QB to tamper with?
 
Advertisement
I see alot of comparisons of Beck to DVD. Beck is a much better athlete that can make things happen with his legs. As far as the picks, I don’t know. I have a die hard Georgia buddy so I will ask him. But we all know DVD could not read a zone defense to save his life. Once defenses figured that out he was toast. Does Beck have that problem? I will find out.
 
TooWise said:
Crazy because I agree! From a talent perspective I like Beck but I know Ewers has more leadership qualities. I would be fine with either tbh
Click to expand...
Also if I’m choosing between Emory/Nickle & Ewers/Beck then the answer is obvious.

Most importantly who would move the needle for portal recruits that are in wait and see mode? Again the answer is obvious

Imagine the media hype if we bring in Ewers/Beck lol

If ward improved like he did (going from an average draft grade to being possibly the #1 pick) being in Dawsons systems then it’s fair to Beck/Ewers would improve and benefit as well.

If Ewers doesn’t get the grade he’s hoping then Mario/Dawson have a VERY strong pitch for him….almost like they can say “come to Miami and improve your draft grade”…….
 
407cane said:
are you talking about the poster, or miami? who says we weren't willing to pay? Mateer to Oklahoma was a done deal a month ago

if anything he just used us to up the price to where he wanted to go
Click to expand...
Then you pay to get him.
Sour grapes.
J smith done deal? Dude hadn’t made up his mind till he called Hayes at 2am.
Picket done deal?
Keyshawn Silver?

Other teams were willing to go where we didn’t until proven other wise.

Hasn’t DMoney said several times that there have been players where Miami didn’t feel that they warranted the money they wanted?
 
Advertisement
DMoney said:
Let’s say Beck and Ewers come back to college.

How many 2025 QBs would you rank ahead of them? I’m assuming it’s a long list, based on the way they’re discussed on here.
Click to expand...
have you seen either of them play bc when you typed that sentence, it shows you haven't and youre just spinning for UMs failure to land a QB
 
Gocanes1990 said:
I trust my eyes. Carson beck is Tyler van cuck but taller. He will lose you games and turn the ball over
Click to expand...
Playing at UGA allowed him to suck for quarters at a time because the defense would keep them in every game. Getting them defensive scores , set them up with short fields or the return game. Once again I ask those to go watch the entire UF game then get back to me. He’s a rollercoaster . It’s hard to suck when you play for the bully and have so many mulligans allowed to you every game. Imagine his record at any other school with that 12-12 td-int ratio versus the Sec?
 
pacusmc said:
Then you pay to get him.
Sour grapes.
J smith done deal? Dude hadn’t made up his mind till he called Hayes at 2am.
Picket done deal?
Keyshawn Silver?

Other teams were willing to go where we didn’t until proven other wise.

Hasn’t DMoney said several times that there have been players where Miami didn’t feel that they warranted the money they wanted?
Click to expand...

the issue is miami is treating their NIL collective amount like its limited to a fake salary cap for principles when it isnt.
 
Cribby said:
Playing at UGA allowed him to suck for quarters at a time because the defense would keep them in every game. Getting them defensive scores , set them up with short fields or the return game. Once again I ask those to go watch the entire UF game then get back to me. He’s a rollercoaster . It’s hard to suck when you play for the bully and have so many mulligans allowed to you every game. Imagine his record at any other school with that 12-12 td-int ratio versus the Sec?
Click to expand...
he was putrid. him and ewers
 
Advertisement
fincane said:
You actually watched Georgia. Cool. So did alot of other people. And Mike Bobo aint the reason Beck was throwing into double and triple coverage against Florida because they broke out a zone defense.

Cam Ward went up because he didn't have to run for his life and Miami is an upgrade talent wise from Washington State. Carson Beck will be taking a step down. He had the best infrastructure he could ever ask for and played poorly. You guys want to lean on the ACC being bad. Cam didn't even get a chance to win the ACC when Miami didn't play the other two best teams in the league during conference play.

Using Emory to bolster the argument is nonsense. If Miami can tamper with a freshman CB at Wisconsin, Miami can tamper with a younger QB someplace else who would likely be less expensive than Beck and leave more money to improve the roster around that QB.
Click to expand...
You’re on fire brother. I’ll throw my panties on stage as appreciation and just watch the show . You’re saving me typing time.
 
Last edited:
Cribby said:
Playing at UGA allowed him to suck for quarters at a time because the defense would keep them in every game. Getting them defensive scores , set them up with short fields or the return game. Once again I ask those to go watch the entire UF game then get back to me. He’s a rollercoaster . It’s hard to suck when you play for the bully and have so many mulligans allowed to you every game. Imagine his record at any other school with that 12-12 td-int ratio versus the Sec?
Click to expand...
It honestly makes me sick to think about.
 
Anyone wanting Beck clearly hasn't seen him play. He's dog water against teams with a pulse. Much better off going through the growing pains with a true freshman Nickle than a one year rental extremely mediocre Beck. Ewers isn't a much better option for that matter, but better than Beck.
 
Advertisement
This Is Not Good Steve Higgins GIF
 
edge said:
I see alot of comparisons of Beck to DVD. Beck is a much better athlete that can make things happen with his legs. As far as the picks, I don’t know. I have a die hard Georgia buddy so I will ask him. But we all know DVD could not read a zone defense to save his life. Once defenses figured that out he was toast. Does Beck have that problem? I will find out.
Click to expand...
Beck has issues with two db’s on one receiver. He likes to throw there
 
canadacanes said:
QB wins is about a useless of a stat as you can get.
Click to expand...
I’ve had a rule since Tebow played for the Broncos and Skip Bayless would fellate him for having a good W-L record while completing 2 passes in games. The rule is if you bring up win Loss record for a qb I instantly stop debating or discussing. I’m out. This isn’t baseball and they aren’t starting pitchers. You can get a win playing one snap and it was a pick.
 
Advertisement
Then
Cribby said:
I’ve had a rule since Tebow played for the Broncos and Skip Bayless would fellate him for having a good W-L record while completing 2 passes in games. The rule is if you bring up win Loss record for a qb I instantly stop debating or discussing. I’m out. This isn’t baseball and they aren’t starting pitchers. You can get a win playing one snap and it was a pick.
Click to expand...
Then where is this going cribby? Mendoza is off the board and Emory isn’t the answer. So who are we getting?
 
Advertisement
Back
Top