forums

Carson Beck

DMoney said:
Let’s say Beck and Ewers come back to college.

How many 2025 QBs would you rank ahead of them? I’m assuming it’s a long list, based on the way they’re discussed on here.
Click to expand...
Maybe only the legend-in-waiting Arch Manning, who has looked great in warm ups as well as on the sideline the last two seasons. Actually, like the GT QB - tough kid, can run a little bit and solid in passing game. The rest of the QBs are all suspect with varying deficiencies.
 

Advertisement
Gocanes1990 said:
He threw 9 picks in three games. He was a meme on SC. Common opponent for next year, UF. Threw three picks, they would have lost if dJ didn’t get knocked out! He was bailed out by an elite defense. He checks down to his TE and RBs. He’s getting processed out at UGA. I feel like I’m being gaslit @DMoney.
Click to expand...

He’s not getting processed out. Their mod actually said if he isn’t going to the NFL, Georgia will welcome him back.

He had a bad stretch but I’m telling you their oline was absolute dog**** mid year and was going through changes due to injuries.
 
Advertisement
gacaneaddict said:
Its not a long list, but Mendoza was a slam
Dunk IMO, and Mario let him walk.

No guarantee coming off injury Beck can be Mendoza.

Right now out current QB situation sits around 12-14th in the ACC.
Click to expand...
I like Mendoza, too. I suspect his reputation on this board will increase now that he’s not coming.

One advantage I see with someone like Beck is that he’d be one and done to hand it off to Luke Nickel. Mendoza had the extra year.
 
DMoney said:
This guy is an NFL draft pick who put up big numbers in the SEC. He’s tall, has a good arm, and can run. Most importantly, he has a ton of experience. Of course he’s better than most college quarterbacks in the country.

If he jumped in the Portal, he would immediately get a huge transfer grade and a ton of calls. I think Cam Ward has distorted our fanbase’s idea of what a good college QB looks like.

Which is why I keep asking: if Beck is trash, who is better in 2025? It should be a long list.
Click to expand...
It’s an insane argument. We all saw Beck play. Yes the SEC is a much tougher conference than the acc. He Will probably boost his stance because of how much worse this conference is alone. But the only thing I watch religiously is college football. My eyes don’t lie to me. Beck had drops for sure, but he was awful vs Bama, Ole Miss, UF, Texas twice. He was heinous vs Georgia tech in the first half. Hes above average and I would take anyone below over him.


- manning, nussmeir, leavitt, sawyer Robertson, Allar (on his best day), sellers, haven’t seen him play yet but probably Sayin. Klubnik, King, Becht, Raoila (probably gonna make a huge leap in year two), Pavia, Mateer, Marcel Reed, Behren Morton. Maybe Mendoza
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
sedlst11 said:
He’s not getting processed out. Their mod actually said if he isn’t going to the NFL, Georgia will welcome him back.

He had a bad stretch but I’m telling you their oline was absolute dog**** mid year and was going through changes due to injuries.
Click to expand...
Don’t have insight into Kirby/Bobo relationship with Beck and family, but unless it’s blown up he’s the best option they have.
 
DMoney said:
They are saying he’s back throwing in spring. Purdy had the same surgery with the same surgeon and had a huge year the next season (Beck’s surgery is two months earlier, too).
Click to expand...

Still not crazy about it. I think I’d have preferred Mendoza. We don’t have many options other than an open comp between Luke and Emory I suppose though.
 
Advertisement
AtlAtty said:
Did you watch any of their games? He single-handedly tried to lose about 3-4 games with his interceptions.
He plays really well in stretches of games and really, really poorly in stretches.

Most of the UGA fans around here are not upset that Brock will be starting the playoff game and feel that Beck was too caught up with the money and fame. He is certainly not viewed at UGA as a worker in the mold of Stetson Bennett.
Click to expand...
Who do you want? Don't give me pie in the sky.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top