Carson Beck

[moneymanj]

yeah, all valid points. I also remember a key 3rd and 17 late in the game they converted. This defense was bad this game and was for much of the year from Vatech on

I still say that the key play of the Gatech was not giving it to Damien Martinez on 4th and 1 on that opening possession of the 2nd half. And then there were FG attempts that were bypassed

The defense was bad vs USF. I knew we had major issues once I saw them kill us with their walk-on slot WR, had him in motion the whole game and we could not stop it. Every offense we faced from then on exposed that, it was all on tape from USF.

 

[TipDrill]

 

[moneymanj]

My worry becomes the LB position. We’ll be fine in the secondary and along the defensive line. LB core is still a huge question mark, in my opinion.

Well at some point these highly touted recruits who want playing time are going to have to start earning it and making plays.

 

[407cane]

That’s similar to saying you would bet Ward would have a higher QBR at Miami than at WSU.

I would too but OU is *** juice and Mateer would have a higher QBR here than Beck would if they were both here.

nah man that's just not a good take.

you or anyone else here didn't even know who mateer was 6 months ago and he played a g5 schedule and now he's the better than carson beck (24-3, 7500 yards, 52td,18 ints, and an SEC title win?)

because he beat some mountain west teams and won 9 games?

beck was legitimately still seen as a first round QB as recently as 2 months ago by some scouts, he'll be fine

in beck's "bad" year, he finished 8th in QBR, in Mateer's best year(against G5), he finished 34th

 

[MidnightCane]

Some ppl on here were willing to take the buffalo qb in his 14th year of eligibility just last night

 

[Hurracanes]

We also need Bain to be at least 2023 Bain (and not 2024 Bain) and at least 2 young DEs to step up (or a quality portal DE).

Too many needs for my taste. I want to know. Heh.

 

[aelmiami]

I agree but Anthony Richardson would like a word with you.

You could sell me on his traits. Could make an argument he could have been like Josh Allen if he hit. Milroe ain’t doing that even if he hits.

 

[canes518]

This guy posts a lot of NFL injury projections based on algorithms and seems to be pretty good. He posted about this Beck recently - expects no dip next season

 

[407cane]

This guy posts a lot of NFL injury projections based on algorithms and seems to be pretty good. He posted about this Beck recently - expects no dip next season View attachment 317132

as long as he's here to learn the playbook and get us enough buzz to land some weapons in the spring window -we're good

he only needs june/july/august for prep and we'll be fine

 

[Ryanmilli]

nah man that's just not a good take.

you or anyone else here didn't even know who mateer was 6 months ago and he played a g5 schedule and now he's the better than carson beck (24-3, 7500 yards, 52td,18 ints, and an SEC title win?)

because he beat some mountain west teams and won 9 games?

beck was legitimately still seen as a first round QB as recently as 2 months ago by some scouts, he'll be fine

in beck's "bad" year, he finished 8th in QBR, in Mateer's best year(against G5), he finished 34th

It’s wild that we’ve got some fans skeptical about a guy who is a third round NFL draft pick today being UMs starting QB next year. Having some reservations about the elbow I can understand. But assuming he’s healthy Beck will be one of the best QBs in CFB next year. And he’s a perfect fit for Dawson’s offense and UMs personnel.

 

[TheOriginalCane]

It’s wild that we’ve got some fans skeptical about a guy who is a third round NFL draft pick today being UMs starting QB next year. Having some reservations about the elbow I can understand. But assuming he’s healthy Beck will be one of the best QBs in CFB next year. And he’s a perfect fit for Dawson’s offense and UMs personnel.

And wait until we add a couple more parts.

 

[JamesQuall]

nah man that's just not a good take.

you or anyone else here didn't even know who mateer was 6 months ago and he played a g5 schedule and now he's the better than carson beck (24-3, 7500 yards, 52td,18 ints, and an SEC title win?)

because he beat some mountain west teams and won 9 games?

beck was legitimately still seen as a first round QB as recently as 2 months ago by some scouts, he'll be fine

in beck's "bad" year, he finished 8th in QBR, in Mateer's best year(against G5), he finished 34th

Sure, whatever dude

 

[The U is back to work]

And wait until we add a couple more parts.

Need a WR1 for sure. The OL and running game are strong and I like the two TEs we have. Just think our WR core is below average right now.

 

[407cane]

Sure, whatever dude

so you think someone with worse stats, worse advanced metric stats, worse scout grades, that played against worse competition would be better

got it

 

[JamesQuall]

so you think some with worse stats, worse advanced metric stats, worse scout grades, that played against worse competition would be better

got it

 

[kccanefan]

My only concern with Beck is the injury. Other than that. Best possible outcome aside from Mateer.

 

[The U is back to work]

I can’t wait for Mateer to get killed every 2 snaps while Beck has a wall keeping him upright

 

[dycane]

My only concern with Beck is the injury. Other than that. Best possible outcome aside from Mateer.

Mine would be the chongas

 

[Calicane02]

Let J Smith get his natty this year, then bring him home for the next two with an offer he can’t refuse.

If wisky is doing this with Xavier Lucas OSU would shoot 4 in the kneecaps and still not let him transfer

 

[vcsu34]

If you are watching these playoffs games you will notice that these quarterbacks are so bad. Carson beck is better than all of these guys.