Bull****. He's had the same trajectory at UM that Randy Shannon has. He's fielded some of the worst defenses in Miami history, and has ONE win at UM against a team with 8 or more wins. So yes, there's plenty of reasons to think he won't win big here.
This is only part of the story. AG has recruited far better than Randy did. Randy signed the 2008 class, quit recruiting, and then watched his dream class, for the most part, do absolutely nothing. AG, instead of losing momentum, seems to be building it. There's a much different vibe around the program now than there was going into Randy's 4th year. If I'm the only one feeling that vibe, so be it.
He's recruited about the same. Golden couldn't even recruit over guys like AJ Highsmith, Kacy Rodgers, Jimmy Gaines, or Shayon Greene, so cool it with the "AG has recruited better" stuff. It's not backed up by fact.
Going into Randy's fourth year, UM was a top 12 team with a positive outlook for the season. We're unranked right now going into Golden's fourth year. I like some things Golden has done this offseason, particularly recruiting, but the "vibe" stuff is revisionist history.
What's revisionist is you, and people like you, speaking about Golden's tenure as if it was an ideal situation.
Shannon left this program in a dumpster, and his ignorance and sheer stupidity almost caused this program to cease to exist.
We were a laughingstock in college football, and an NFL joke when Golden took over. We were also pretty much shut out of the best recruiting area in the country thanks to Shannon's myopia.
The reason Golden has great national respect amongst his peers, even if a few local morons belittle him, is because he has done quite a bit with very little, in the worst imaginable situation for a head coach.
Shannon was garbage as a head coach and while I concede Golden is and relationship builder, it hasn't translated to **** on the field,
which is all that matters at the end of the day.
The majority of this porst speaks to "vibe," "feel," and just about anything else other than on-field results.
Say whatever you want about the way Randy left this team: There is no excuse, even with the personnel Golden has been dealt, to field defenses this poorly and underachieve against so many mediocre teams.
It's also pretty funny how we were a "laughingstock in college football" when Golden took over, yet FSU fans were laughing their asses off in celebration after Golden didn't get PSU job.
Take into account the way the season ended, the fact more and more fans are cognizant of the **** defenses we have field, all combined with the PSU fiasco and we're still a laughingstock. The only way this will change is producing on the field.