Scrimmage take...

[Calinative]

119 yards per game is playing well? That’s winning in the trenches?

https://gyazo.com/00989b52f9b60540129baf0ac84ef9cf

 

[Dwinstitles]

Bama qbs were better than rosier. Greg mcelroy for his career at bama completed 66% of his passes. His senior year he completed 70%.

Aj mccaron never completed less than 62% of his passes and never threw over 7 picks in a season.

Those guys won't elite but they were accurate, took care of the ball, and got it to the recievers when it was time.

I just think so highly of the 00 01 02 sqauds that i think most qbs could win a title, that team won a title without a coach at all thats how great they were. What bama does now is copy that blue print......monster lines athletes everywhere and elite rbs wrs dbs u name it

 

[Loose Cannon]

https://gyazo.com/00989b52f9b60540129baf0ac84ef9cf

Now you’re comparing 3 RBs to 1. Barkley, Fournette, and Cook all averaged over 100 yards each. Our 3 backs combined only averaged 119.

119 ypg rushing was good enough to rank 113th out of 130 teams last season.

Like I said earlier. We only managed to make it all the way up to 79th thanks to Rosier’s record season.

 

[Calinative]

Now you’re comparing 3 RBs to 1. Barkley, Fournette, and Cook all averaged over 100 yards each. Our 3 backs combined only averaged 119.

119 ypg rushing was good enough to rank 113th out of 130 teams last season.

Like I said earlier. We only managed to make it all the way up to 79th thanks to Rosier’s record season.

1) Walton only played in one game that I have listed - FSU. In that game Homer only got 3 carries and Dallas got 0. In the other 4 games only Homer and Deejay had any carries. So no, I'm not actually comparing the work of 3 RBs in a game to one.
2) Carries per game (I should have listed this on there, but I underestimated your stupidity I guess)
Our RBs - 21 Carries/game
Fournett - 19.25
Cook - 18 Carries/game
Barkley - 17.65 carries/game.
This isn't like our guys were out carrying them by some wild amount.
3) Just ******* look at the PER ATTEMPT/CARRY STAT. Remember when I was saying its useless to compare anybody unless its using per attempt? Well this is the situation I'm talking about. Our guys In our 5 most important games of the season on a per carry basis were just slightly worse than 3 of the top CFB RBs in the last 2 years.

 

[Loose Cannon]

Wtf are you talking about you've been tongue punching your boy okie cane's taint. Bro you're on some other **** on the autism spectrum if you're bashing Travis homer rn. What is there to be honest about? Our starting rb lol he's a beast

WTF am I talking about? Okay. Let me explain to you how this is about to go down. You have on at least 5 occasions referenced a chart created by @calinative umstudent that shows how inaccurate Rosier was last season. You have 3 options. 1. You can man up and admit you’re full of **** and will pretty much say anything and then lie about it if you think it helps your argument. 2. You can be the little puss you are and go back and edit those references out of all of your posts. 3. I’ll do just like I did a few pages ago when you lied about never trashing Rosier and pull all those posts together into one and repost it for you.

You are wrong and you are a liar. And now you’re trying to lie about what I’ve said. I never trashed Walton. Saying he gained 12 yards behind miserable O-line play is trashing the O-line. You know that, but it doesn’t help your case so you have to lie.

 

[Calinative]

WTF am I talking about? Okay. Let me explain to you how this is about to go down. You have on at least 5 occasions referenced a chart created by @calinative umstudent that shows how inaccurate Rosier was last season. You have 3 options. 1. You can man up and admit you’re full of **** and will pretty much say anything and then lie about it if you think it helps your argument. 2. You can be the little puss you are and go back and edit those references out of all of your posts. 3. I’ll do just like I did a few pages ago when you lied about never trashing Rosier and pull all those posts together into one and repost it for you.

You are wrong and you are a liar. And now you’re trying to lie about what I’ve said. I never trashed Walton. Saying he gained 12 yards behind miserable O-line play is trashing the O-line. You know that, but it doesn’t help your case so you have to lie.

maybe hes commenting on my little quick charts because you have had absolutely no response to them.
Its like you don't want to believe the objective numbers I'm giving. And you're acting like the ONLY thing Rosier was bad at was Comp%, but thats not true. Secondly you're acting like a low Comp% isn't that important. You're just wrong.

 

[Loose Cannon]

1) Walton only played in one game that I have listed - FSU. In that game Homer only got 3 carries and Dallas got 0. In the other 4 games only Homer and Deejay had any carries. So no, I'm not actually comparing the work of 3 RBs in a game to one.
2) Carries per game (I should have listed this on there, but I underestimated your stupidity I guess)
Our RBs - 21 Carries/game
Fournett - 19.25
Cook - 18 Carries/game
Barkley - 17.65 carries/game.
This isn't like our guys were out carrying them by some wild amount.
3) Just ******* look at the PER ATTEMPT/CARRY STAT. Remember when I was saying its useless to compare anybody unless its using per attempt? Well this is the situation I'm talking about. Our guys In our 5 most important games of the season on a per carry basis were just slightly worse than 3 of the top CFB RBs in the last 2 years.

Is 119 ypg from your running backs adequate for a top 25 team? Yes or no. Name 1 team in the Top 25 with 119 ypg or less.

 

[Loose Cannon]

maybe hes commenting on my little quick charts because you have had absolutely no response to them.
Its like you don't want to believe the objective numbers I'm giving. And you're acting like the ONLY thing Rosier was bad at was Comp%, but thats not true. Secondly you're acting like a low Comp% isn't that important. You're just wrong.

We have 4 National titles won by QBs with completion percentages ranging from 53-59. The greatest college football team of all time had a 56% completion percentage.

It’s not that important to have a QB that is 60%

You are wrong.

 

[Calinative]

Is 119 ypg from your running backs adequate for a top 25 team? Yes or no. Name 1 team in the Top 25 with 119 ypg or less.

We didn't average 119 ypg or less. In those 5 games we averaged 162 ypg. Maybe you don't know this but our offense does involve the rpo.
I think 160 yards rushing per game between the RB and QB IN OUR BIG GAMES is enough to win a championship IF our QB is not enept, yes.
...but I think our Running game will be even bettter this year. Further reason starting Rosier is stupid.

 

[Cribby]

You do realize that this wasn't just for the first half. Also, again, his accuracy (or lack thereof) is merely the main focal point; not the only shortcoming he has as a QB. He doesn't know how to go through his progressions, he locks onto his first receiver, etc...

Sure, Rosier has brass balls. But always remember that GT game was sheer luck that we didn't lose - that ball should've been at the very least knocked away which would've put the game away since it was a 4th down conversion to Langham - Rosier literally underthrew Langham in double coverage. 99 times out of 100 that's at least incomplete.

Ironically a poster named loose cannon is always making excuses for our loose cannon qb.

 

[Cribby]

We have 4 National titles won by QBs with completion percentages ranging from 53-59. The greatest college football team of all time had a 56% completion percentage.

It’s not that important to have a QB that is 60%

You are wrong.

Jesus you’re awful , quit comparing stats to 18-30 years ago.

It’s not the same, especially qb stats.

I don’t get how that’s hard to understand for you and Okie.

 

[Calinative]

We have 4 National titles won by QBs with completion percentages ranging from 53-59. The greatest college football team of all time had a 56% completion percentage.

It’s not that important to have a QB that is 60%

You are wrong.

bruh Rosier had a ******* sub 50% comp % in over half our ******* games. lol. You're sitting here talking about it not being important to get to 60%, meanwhile Rosier can't even ******* get to 50%!

Secondly Idgaf what someones completion percentage was pre 2ks and when the passing game started to become waay more important.
Why don't you look at all the qbs who have won a national championship and see what their completion percentage is. I guarantee you in the last 20 years the vast majority (probably like 90%) have had >60% comp%.

 

[orange&green84]

Yeezus now we are bashing homer because our love for rosier is so great

I got called out earlier for not being a Canes fan given my criticism of Rosier. It comes full circle, now they're bashing actual quality players.

 

[orange&green84]

Jesus you’re awful , quit comparing stats to 18-30 years ago.

It’s not the same, especially qb stats.

I don’t get how that’s hard to understand for you and Okie.

What? You didn't know that offenses have stayed the same over the years? They're now different now than when they were wearing leather helmets. At least that's what's being conveyed to me.

 

[Loose Cannon]

1) Walton only played in one game that I have listed - FSU. In that game Homer only got 3 carries and Dallas got 0. In the other 4 games only Homer and Deejay had any carries. So no, I'm not actually comparing the work of 3 RBs in a game to one.
2) Carries per game (I should have listed this on there, but I underestimated your stupidity I guess)
Our RBs - 21 Carries/game
Fournett - 19.25
Cook - 18 Carries/game
Barkley - 17.65 carries/game.
This isn't like our guys were out carrying them by some wild amount.
3) Just ******* look at the PER ATTEMPT/CARRY STAT. Remember when I was saying its useless to compare anybody unless its using per attempt? Well this is the situation I'm talking about. Our guys In our 5 most important games of the season on a per carry basis were just slightly worse than 3 of the top CFB RBs in the last 2 years.

And you left out the Pitt game for some reason. What? The team that ruined our perfect season doesn’t count as an important game, or does 16 yards rushing by Dallas and Homer combined mess up your little chart?

 

[Loose Cannon]

We didn't average 119 ypg or less. In those 5 games we averaged 162 ypg. Maybe you don't know this but our offense does involve the rpo.
I think 160 yards rushing per game between the RB and QB IN OUR BIG GAMES is enough to win a championship IF our QB is not enept, yes.
...but I think our Running game will be even bettter this year. Further reason starting Rosier is stupid.

Nope. You can’t count Rosier’s numbers. He’s the reason we lost games remember. He’s the reason games were close when we should have been blowing everyone out. Get the **** off his numbers.

 

[Calinative]

And you left out the Pitt game for some reason. What? The team that ruined our perfect season doesn’t count as an important game, or does 16 yards rushing by Dallas and Homer combined mess up your little chart?

No it doesn't count. That should have been an easy win. Did you want me to include UNC and GTech too because we almost lost to them due to you're butt buddy being a **** qb?
Pitt isn't even close to the quality opponent the 5 I'm using are. And If i did use pitt it would just make Rosier look even worse, same with UNC.

 

[Calinative]

Nope. You can’t count Rosier’s numbers. He’s the reason we lost games remember. He’s the reason games were close when we should have been blowing everyone out. Get the **** off his numbers.

ROSIER AS A ******* PASSER YOU ******* IDIOT.
holy **** dude. are you really this thick right now? haha
Im pretty sure I've never said Rosier was a bad runner. Not great but definitely not bad.

 

[Loose Cannon]

bruh Rosier had a ******* sub 50% comp % in over half our ******* games. lol. You're sitting here talking about it not being important to get to 60%, meanwhile Rosier can't even ******* get to 50%!

Secondly Idgaf what someones completion percentage was pre 2ks and when the passing game started to become waay more important.
Why don't you look at all the qbs who have won a national championship and see what their completion percentage is. I guarantee you in the last 20 years the vast majority (probably like 90%) have had >60% comp%.

Bruh, in 2001 Miami had two close games. VaTech and BC. Ken Dorsey was 49% and 47% in those two games. No doubt we should have benched him for a freshman in 2002

 

[Loose Cannon]

ROSIER AS A ******* PASSER YOU ******* IDIOT.
holy **** dude. are you really this thick right now? haha
Im pretty sure I've never said Rosier was a bad runner. Not great but definitely not bad.

Rosier is a ******* quarterback you ******* idiot. We run a ******* balanced Pro-style offense you ******* idiot. Passing is literally less than half his ******* job you ******* idiot. That’s why your stupid ******* chart that covers less than ******* half of what a ******* quarterback is ******* responsible for doesn’t ******* matter one ******* bit you ******* sad little ******* loser.

See. I know how to use swear words, too.