forums

Pro Football Hall of Fame finalists

Rellyrell said:
Sharpe should’ve been in 10 yrs ago, & I will forever hate CIS for making defend a Green Bay Packer, especially one that was part of the turn around that have fck’d over my Bears for 3 decades.

Thanks guys
Click to expand...
I avoided Sharpe discussion, but no real fan is questioning his selection.
 
Advertisement
Rellyrell said:
Now fam, if I were to provide a list of all the players that were ahead of Reggie in 2001-3, 2004, 2011, 2012-14, it would be too exhaustive.
Click to expand...
But it would be worth it. I love reading this stuff! (just not putting in the work lol) Great work.

Honestly not sure what he'd look like in a different system. Part of me thinks Harrison/Edge hurt him and part of me thinks maybe he benefited and maxed out his potential. Let me smoke again real quick and overanalyze before deciding which one is more likely. Lol I kid.

(I do realize stats only matter so much due to the league changing as well)

My vote is for BOFA DEM.
 
L A M P said:
But it would be worth it. I love reading this stuff! (just not putting in the work lol) Great work.

Honestly not sure what he'd look like in a different system. Part of me thinks Harrison/Edge hurt him and part of me thinks maybe he benefited and maxed out his potential. Let me smoke again real quick and overanalyze before deciding which one is more likely. Lol I kid.

(I do realize stats only matter so much due to the league changing as well)

My vote is for BOFA DEM.
Click to expand...

Yeah, & that’s another factor to consider. However I will say this: unlike guys like Alvin Harper, TJ Houz, & several others who were clear #2’s, Wayne proved he was really a #1 when Harrison retired. Those other guys flamed when they were called upon to be a #1. I think Reggie is underrated, & that’s not me being a homer.

If I was a voter, I’ll be honest: I wouldn’t put him on the 1st ballot, but pound for pound w/ total yards, total receptions w/ the SB ring, I would have him in 3rd ballot compared to his peers.
 
Rellyrell said:
Derek Jeter:
-5x Champion
-14x All Star
-.310 career batting avg.
-3000+ career hits
-1300+ RBIs
-5x Gold Glove
-5x Silver Slugger
-MVP
-ROY
-WS MVP
-2x Hank Aaron Award Winner

What r u talking about? This is about as close to a 100% sure 1st ballot resume in MLB history. Lol.
Click to expand...
3465 hits
8 200 hit seasons
100 runs scored 13 times

Saying an above average hitter is way off
 
I look forward to CIS going back-and-forth and arguing why Mike Evans should not be in the Hall of Fame.

When that time comes.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Back
Top