Gotta think that the guys against hiring Butch as an analyst have to be of the younger guys on here and have no clue what Butch helped this program accomplish with the recruits he brought here.
Not all the kids he recruited were 4-5* but with his evaluations a lot of 3* ended up looking like 4-5 *.
Butch would be one of the first calls I’d make if I’m looking for someone to help with evals…Will Mario? Who knows.
But if Mario does or doesn’t should never be the final judge as to if he’s qualified or not.Personally I hope Butch's phone rings from Mario.If it doesn’t that’s Marios call but never ever doubt the qualifications of Butch Davis as a judge of talent..only one close to him in my mind is JJ and I doubt there would be one one person against him if we were talking about JJ and not Butch.
Yet he just got fired from a job in the most fertile recruiting area in the country where him and his evals went 1-18 against a crap schedule in his last 19 games (his only win was against some 2-8 thing called Long Island University which spends its Saturdays losing in the Northeast League, a commuter school tri-state conference).
1-18. Really process that. It's HARD to be that bad.
He turned FIU into the worst program in America. We just can't sweep that under the rug and it deserves discussion. Does he still have the ability to evaluate HS kids in this day and age? Maybe. Maybe not. But the most recent evidence should give us major pause.
I loved Butch when he was here. I mean, he was from the JJ tree too and was part of that staff before he even came back. Yes, he built the GOAT UM roster 20+ years ago. While many don't, I actually forgive him for how he left. He deserves a TON of credit for getting UM back on track. And I wish him as well as one could and hope in his retirement he has a relationship with the U. But if we are being objective, the man has a lot of baggage and a lot of failures on his resume, and if he is being brought on just to evaluate talent, Mario is going to have to ask himself (and maybe Butch) why his evaluations led FIU down the toilet.
The great news is if this ever got any legs, Mario and the U would surely take a deep dive with him, deeper than any of us could, and Mario, as an experienced top head coach will make a decision. So whatever happens, we know that the due diligence will have been done and the decision will have been made by someone qualified to figure out the Davis puzzle.
I still can't believe what's happened to him, that it's ended this poorly. It's really sad.