He wouldnt have ever fired Radio. We would still be stuck with Radio on the sideline looking lost.
No...Butch. Everyone wants to hire Butch. That's always the answer by anyone wanting to toss Golden off the train these days. That, or Schiano.
Never. Ever. Would have hired Golden. Wrong coaching tree.
OK, that's reasonable. That's probably the best reason I've heard someone give for not hiring Golden to begin with, as I think coaching trees are indeed important. Learning defensive principles from Al Groh used to be a good thing in the late 90's/early 2000's, but now as time has gone on and the game has changed a bit--his system hasn't stood the test of time.
I've killed you for bad posts in the past, so here's me giving you credit for a good one. That makes sense.
Second. Never, EVER would have extended his contract. Until one of these coaches is playing in the NC game three consecutive years, winning two, I'd have a two-year, out-front, rolling contract.
I can agree with not extending Golden as far out as we did, but I think when the timing of when we gave him the extension was good. Along with "the cloud", there was tons of uncertainty affecting the recruiting class that season about whether or not Golden would stay...the extension helped land us some guys like Duke, Howard, Bush, Kirby, Malcolm Lewis, Ereck Flowers, Waters, McCord, etc...in that 2012 class. Without that extension, some of those guys wouldn't be on campus right now. Extending him out to 2020 was a bit much--2018 or 2019 would have made more sense
with less cash committed.
I have to pick on you for the last part of your post though--if you offered any big-time collegiate coach worth his salt
an initial contract of 3 years, then a rolling 2-year contract after that, they'd never take it. Not for all the tea in China. No way, no how. Even Golden, as bad as he's believed by most to be, would balk hard at signing a contract like that...even if he felt he had a bunch to prove. Head Coaches would turn over like hotcakes at IHOP in this program if we tried a stunt like that.
I'll give you credit for wanting to set the bar Saban-high, but until we have a guy that actually takes Miami back up to that echelon where Bama and Saban currently reside...we don't have the stick to swing to make your contract demands happen.