I strongly disagree with everything you said above. You may be the only one that supports Newton and the above given his actual tenure.
1. Newton has been an atrocious defender his whole career. Find someone who thinks he isn't a defensive liability. Then find someone that thinks Lykes is inferior to him at D. Newton has such a low basketball IQ, especially on D, and that foul on McMahon is further proof as such. I guess the double team wasn't enough, Newton needed to foul him too.
2. You failed to mention that Newton is incredibly selfish and had some awful offensive possessions when it mattered. He shot 2-10 for the game and this included going 0-2 from FG and 2-4 from the FTL in OT. I don't see how Lykes does worse during that time.
3. As for that Snider stuff, he had 5 of his 6 FGs in the second half. Who do you think was guarding him getting all that burn? Also, 6 for 15 isn't impressive. He normally shoots 43% and he shot 40% and it was a road game. Snider also scored 18 total points, 5 more than average.
Lykes has done well defensively when he is in there, however [MENTION=18929]miamidan20[/MENTION] is right about last night. Louisville was going right at Lykes inside and they got a clean look every time. I'll add that while I think Newton isn't a good 1v1 defender he certainly has more experience as a team defender, less likely to make a mistake IMO.
Even if you think that Newton played better D than Newton, which I disagree with, the other stuff still stood out. When it mattered most he couldn’t hit a layup, went 2-4 from FTL and played selfish with the ball.
I'm with Consigliere on this one. I'm glad we won and all, but Coach L's decision to keep Newton in during the last couple of minutes of regulation had me extremely concerned. Two missed layups and two turnovers in 90 seconds is not how you want to close out the game. Plus, I thought we needed Lykes to provide a spark, especially during the first couple of minutes of OT, when we were standing around and taking jump shots (and missing them).
First off, my post was a comment on Lykes only as to his defensive issues early in this game and the reason that he only played about 5 second half minutes. I love Lykes, this is not a Jaquan/Lykes debate in general. They played together a lot in the game actually (which I really liked, particularly with the way Brown was struggling). But we beat a very good team that we were losing to for most of the game in part because of the decisions that Coach L made re: Newton and Lykes (the other major parts being Lonnie and team rebounding - of which 6’2 Newton had 7 by the way). Did you guys even read coach L’s post-game quotes? “Then Jaquan Newton just took over the game with his defensive effort and he sent a message to everybody on the team: you’ve got to pick it up and play a lot harder”. I’m sorry if I’m the “only one” in here that supports Newton. I’m hoping that some of you will come along with me (and Coach L) as the season goes on.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm certainly with you (and Coach L). I also really want the best for Newton, and am not as down on him as others are. If we want to achieve all that we hoped for at the beginning of the season, we need Newton and Brown to be major contributors. For most of the game, I thought Newton played well. Up until the last 90 seconds in regulation, Newton was 2-6 from the floor, but 6-6 from the line, and with 0 turnovers. So, on his 9 "possessions" (6 FG attempts and 3 trips to the line), he had 10 points. That's a great number against a solid Louisville defense that clogs the lane and takes away Newton's primary skill.
Where I thought Newton should be removed was in OT. Consider his stat line starting with the last 90 seconds of regulation:
0-4 FG
2-4 FT
1 turnover
1 steal
4 rebounds (which were big, especially on Brown's second missed FT)
2 fouls (with one horrific foul on McMahon's 3-point attempt in OT)
He made some important plays in OT to be sure, especially the rebounds and the steal, but he also made some bad decisions. If he had played even an average last 90 seconds of regulation, I would have fully supported Coach L's decision to keep Newton in the game in OT. But he seemed to slip into the reckless version of Newton that we have seen too often this year. Hopefully, he can learn to work with the team, and not try to be the entire team, which he seems to do at times. We need his skill set, especially against a team like FSU.
Last edited: