I fully agree with your take here and I want to take this opportunity to express my thoughts on the Masterclass that Guidry put out there. It was purely complexity with a KISS (Keep-It-Simple-Stupid) flare. As you stated, much of what we did isn't any different than what we have been doing the first 6 gamees, however, just the personnel changed to bring more speed and experience on the field. With the WILL walking down, it's no different that the Jack DE in this defense that will either rush or drop back in coverage. Difference to a normal fan is that they will not scream at the TV when they see a LB drop back versus a DE.
I can write a book on everything I seen and witness, but between you,
@Lance Roffers,
@Memnon, and a few others. There's no need as we everyone gets the point. However, I will say that I've always been an advocate for Miami to adopt more of the 3-3-5 defense, but with sound principles like Guidry displayed. Not the model where there's no gap integrity. Reason being is because of the location and the type of kids we have in South Florida and throughout the State. We don't have the luxury of the SEC big-Bodied athletic DT down here. We gets those once in a blue moon, but we do have a ton of twitchy 3-tech DT or undersized (height-wise) stocky DE that can play the 4i positions in the 3-3-5 and abuse OL with their strength and quickness. Also, the NT is proven in this defense to not have to be a 310+ guy as he typically lined up over the center in a stacked look. He can play violent with his hands and push the center back on his heels and beat em with quickness which is exactly what LT strength is (one-on-one versus holding point on combo blocks) Guards often can't combo block the NT that much because the 4i DE is playing too tight and can just shoot the gap. It's flawless for the guys we can get. Plus we have an abundance of guys in South FL that are LB bodies but play DE in high school because they can wreck the game. Same thing applies here where you have your OLB cause havoc for OL by beating them to blocking points and have the power to knock them back as well when put in the right strength and conditioning program. Sprinkle this with some quality ILB that are pure knockback tacklers and you have the best thing smoking.
If they need to deploy this defense again I would personally like to see Cyrus Moss switch rooms and get some experience for the OLB role which fits his body type more and he's already had to deal with the physicality on the line albeit he isn't fully there yet, but his weight isn't worldly different than wes although wes could possibly be a better player, Cyrus has the length to make a difference when rushing the passer with his bend. Also, he has longer arms to disrupt passing lanes when dropping into coverage. Ultimately, he would be a great depth piece with what you have.
Doubt Mario would adopt this approach due to 3-3-5 being known to be weak against the run against prominent teams, however, if you have the right pieces and play sound, last Saturday showed the issues it presents. It allows for you to bring various fronts with dynamic personnel based on body types. It's a defense predicated for tweeners, which we've always had in South Florida since forever.
***Disclaimer*** This doesn't mean I don't want them to recruit bigger players (pause) I'm just saying this defense can provide a ton of flexibility with what you have and what you can get out there.