Dumf af.
Did you know that there are more 4 and 5 star rated kids each year than there are TOTAL NFL DRAFT PICKS? By a LOT. Whoops. Yep, the 36th best player in the US and the 377th best player in the US are both... rated 4-star kids. LOL. In the draft that's the difference between a $9M NFL contract and submitting an application at Enterprise Rent-A-Car.
Guess what? That's the dirty little secret that the websites pull on what they see as math-illiterate people like yourself. The websites give themselves a ton of chips to spread around and then get to say they were right. There are only about 256 picks in the NFL Draft (including compensatory). And there are 377 4 and 5 star kids as I type this on 247. The 377th best player in the NFL Draft isn't even getting a UFA INVITE. But they get to say he's a 4-star. And you fall for it.
You're telling me that more 4 and 5 stars gets drafted than 3 stars? LOL. I would f'ing hope so. When they give a kid a 3-star rating they are basically telling you they would hypothetically project him in the 12th - 20th rounds of an endless draft. Yet a ton break through, even into the first round. As do 2-star and unrated kids they totally miss. Because outside of the obvious kid's that my blind grandmother could point out as obviously the best kid on the field, the unqualified hacks that rate these kids are throwing darts. They just gives themselves 10x as many darts as they should need to assure "success." And they still fail a ton.