JustCanesBaby
Redshirt Freshman
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2012
- Messages
- 206
If you are good enough to leave after three years, you can contribute as a freshman, and you shouldn't be red shirted. We aren't Alabama guys, yet anyway. We can't just red-shirt talent that can go to the NFL after three seasons.
If you have watched college football for a long time you know that statement is not true. Like I said I'm not saying Coley is going to redshirt or just because he says the next 3-4 years he'll be at Miami literally means he'll be leaving after 3 years.
All of the following players redshirted, left after 3 years and were picked in the 1st round(except bold which were 2nd round):
Aldon Smith
Justin Blackmon
Michael Crabtree
Ryan Williams(VT)
Michael Brockers (LSU DT)
Matt Kalil
Andrew Luck
Dontari Poe
Riley Reiff
Giovani Bernard
Zach Ertz
Barkevious Mingo
Earl Thomas
All these players did not come from top 5 schools. If a player has the physical talent but still needs the mental or additional strength and additional learning there is nothing wrong with redshirting.