The general consensus on CIS is that kids that reclassify often either are busts or don't live up to the hype. However, not a lot of hard evidence. After seeing a post from
@Ghandi ,
@Gi0logy suggested that we create a thread to track this long term and see if the CIS hypothesis can be verified. Please post names of kids that have reclassified and we'll add them to the OP. Also, let me know if we should add any additional data to the table.
It could be that the skill position players can reclassify and live up to expectations while the big uglies need the time to mature. We'll see.
Recruit | Position | Age | Rating before | Rating After | Class | Original Class | NLI | School | Portal entries | Portal
School | Consensus |
Malachi Toney | WR | 17 | 4* | TBD | 25 | 26 | | Miami | | | |
Demetres Samuel Jr | CB | | 4* | 4* | 25 | 26 | | Gators | | | |
Armondo Blount | DT | | 5* | 5* | 24 | 25 | Miami | Miami | | | Already getting PT his freshman year |
Amaree Williams | DE | | 4* | ? | 24 | 25 | FSU | FSU | | | UM likely would have made him a priority if he remained in the 25 class. |
Ryan "Hollywood" Williams | WR | | 5* | ? | 24 | 25 | Bama | Bama | | | |
Davon Mitchell | TE | | 5* | 4* | 24 | 25 | Oklahoma | Oklahoma | | | |
Kevyn “Kerm” Humes | CB | | 4* | | 24 | | | | | | |
TJ Capers | DE/LB | | 5* | 4* | 23 | 24 | Louisville | Louisville | | | Reclassified very late in the cycle (July) after an ACL. Much negativity on CIS about him being tweener |
Austin Jackson | QB | | 4* | 3* | 23 | 25 | Ole Miss | Ole Miss | | | Apparently old for his class and would've aged out. Had credits to graduate. Reclassified two years! Committed to the Gators then flipped to Ole Miss. |
Antoine Jackson | CB | | 5* | 4* | 23 | 24 | Miami | ECU | | | Very good FR year.
2024: in the portal |
Desmond Ricks | CB | | 5* | | 23 | | Bama | Bama | | | |
Donnel Harris | DE | | 5* | 4* | 20 | | A&M | A&M | | | Disappointing career and medically retired. Was a lot older than HS competition and undersized for college. |
Tony Grimes | CB | | 5* | 4* | 20 | 20 | UNC | UNC | 2 | A&M | Contributed as a FR, started at UNC for a couple of years. Has not lived up to 5* potential. Many on CIS labeled him a bust.
2023: in the portal
2024: in the portal |
Mark Walton | RB | | 4* | 4* | 15 | 15 | Miami | Miami | | | Very productive college career. Some legal issues in college and serious legal woes after being drafted by the NFL. |