forums

QBS in the Portal as of 11/28

E1k said:
Because Ewers isn’t good. And you said they have similarities lmao no they dont at all. You said we are underestimating what hitting routine plays would do…WE HAD THE #1 OFFENSE..Best passing game BY FAR.

Its just hilarious to see people talking about routine plays and hero ballto cope for the next guy because that **** just is nitpicking…We dont have the #1 offense if cam is turning down routine plays more like yall think he was
Click to expand...

These are your subjective opinions against objective film and Dawson saying he 'prefers the routine play' as well.

I'm not going to debate your belief system but you need to support it with something other than opinionated statements presented as fact...which they are not.

Eita GIF by TVE Bahia
 

Advertisement
E1k said:
Richardson showed way more translatable stuff on film than milroe imo. And he literally tested as the best athlete ever at qb, plus people looked at a small sample size and gambled on that. If they had a bigger sample size the evaluation would be different for AR
Click to expand...
Yea, this isn't how it actually works. NFL GMs aren't what you are making them out to be.
 
Bunker Mentality said:
These are your subjective opinions against objective film and Dawson saying he 'prefers the routine play' as well.

I'm not going to debate your belief system but you need to support it with something other than opinionated statements presented as fact...which they are not.

Eita GIF by TVE Bahia
Click to expand...
Cam took the routine plays way more than yall are understanding..We would not have the #1 passing offense by far if he didn’t.

If you think the film doesn’t back up cam taking routine plays you haven’t watched it. And of course dawson says he prefers that, every oc does. If you think that meant cam isn’t making those then you haven’t actually watched the film

And literally every stat or data you look up will prove he took the routine plays . You dont have the most efficient and best passing offenses by far if you are consistently turning down routine plays.
 
cway313 said:
Yea, this isn't how it actually works. NFL GMs aren't what you are making them out to be.
Click to expand...
Im not making them out to be anything lol its just common sense and what was said about why teams bet on AR.

He had a small sample size that they liked, milroe has a big sample size. Milroe doesn’t process in the pocket like ar did, he isn’t the same level athlete and he isn’t mfin 6’4 240

Maybe if milroe stays another year and shows big improvements he could go 1st but this year after what he has shown? **** naw
 
E1k said:
Im not making them out to be anything lol its just common sense and what was said about why teams bet on AR.

He had a small sample size that they liked, milroe has a big sample size. Milroe doesn’t process in the pocket like ar did, he isn’t the same level athlete and he isn’t mfin 6’4 240

Maybe if milroe stays another year and shows big improvements he could go 1st but this year after what he has shown? **** naw
Click to expand...
Literally every year GMs draft questionable guys in the first round off sheer measurables. You are pretending like they use some science. He will throw the ball far and run fast. Those attributes equate to being drafted too high.
 
Advertisement
cway313 said:
Literally every year GMs draft questionable guys in the first round off sheer measurables. You are pretending like they use some science. He will throw the ball far and run fast. Those attributes equate to being drafted too high.
Click to expand...
I just named basic ****, why do u think thats me saying they use some science? You acting like im defending the **** lmao, i just don’t think as of right now milroe is similar to the questionable guys they have recently drafted first round
 
E1k said:
I just named basic ****, why do u think thats me saying they use some science? You acting like im defending the **** lmao, i just don’t think as of right now milroe is similar to the questionable guys they have recently drafted first round
Click to expand...
When guys like Jaden Daniels have success GMs think they can recreate it. I will take any bet that if Milroe runs sub 4.5 he goes 1st round. It's really simple.
 
Bunker Mentality said:
These are your subjective opinions against objective film and Dawson saying he 'prefers the routine play' as well.

I'm not going to debate your belief system but you need to support it with something other than opinionated statements presented as fact...which they are not.

Eita GIF by TVE Bahia
Click to expand...
Ewers would be a phenomenal pickup. Beck too if his elbow checks out. I’m kind of floored there is even a debate on here whether picking up productive SEC QBs with significant experience is a good idea.

Not a big fan of Milroe though and do not think his strengths align well with Dawson’s system.
 
Advertisement
Ryanmilli said:
Ewers would be a phenomenal pickup. Beck too if his elbow checks out. I’m kind of floored there is even a debate on here whether picking up productive SEC QBs with significant experience is a good idea.

Not a big fan of Milroe though and do not think his strengths align well with Dawson’s system.
Click to expand...

Inshallah. Milroe improved as a passer and is better than what we currently have, but I have faith we'll find a passer to run the offense.
 
E1k said:
Eh i guess. Ill take him but i dont think its a good fit
Click to expand...
I think it's a excellent fit for him. We all know he's runs well so our RPO as well as play action Game lethal. It's simple basic routes for our WRs for him to develop better, and the biggest thing is our offense is aggressive and throws the deep ball a ton and that's already his strength
 
Advertisement
Odysseus said:
I think it's a excellent fit for him. We all know he's runs well so our RPO as well as play action Game lethal. It's simple basic routes for our WRs for him to develop better, and the biggest thing is our offense is aggressive and throws the deep ball a ton and that's already his strength
Click to expand...
Ill take him but rpo isn’t a huge part of dawson natural bag, alot of his offense is pure drop back where the qb has to diagnose the defense and find the answers.

So the play actions aren’t really a huge factor because i dont think the run and pass game is totally meshed together..Its kinda simple tells on when we are throwing or running but it works because we have the oline to block it and this year we had the qb to find the answers consistently or create them if they aren’t there

Idk if milroe fits that but im sure some adjustments can be made so ill take him. A milroe type player in college is gonna win you games if the support system is good so he would be a huge get even if the fit isn’t great
 
Advertisement
E1k said:
I agree

If he enters the draft this year I’ll bet.
Click to expand...
You're going to lose 1000%. Only chance you have honestly is if Allar, Nussmeier, Ewers, and Beck all also declare. Too many teams NEED a Qb. Then maybe theres the chance one of them becomes 3rd Qb off the board. But someone will trade back up to end of 1st for Milroe if he makes it that far.
 
supersaiyanshel said:
Milroe is my guy to target (the 5th one this window :ROFLMAO: ).

Pretty sure Bama would like for him to look elsewhere, and he probably would like a new start as well.

Won't come cheap, and we'd probably have to compete with ND and maybe even USC, but pair him with Martinez and our line and you won't have much drop off in offense. We need a threat to run as our signal caller. We won't have much of a intermediate-pass game, but the deep ball would go crazy.

It's still all about the defense with this team.

We lost every game this season by one possession. We just need to be a smidgen better to get to the ACCCG.
Click to expand...

Plus you didn’t mention they signed arguably the best HS in this past cycle (or #2, at least). Not a lot of teams are paying 2 QBs premium NIL deals
 
Advertisement
Back
Top