If Kinchens & JWill had stayed, do we make the CFP?

[NJshoreCane]

If you need an nfl safety to competently run your defense and for the defense to be at least average, then you are the problem.

“Good” college safety play gets a W vs GT or SU.

 

[TRick72]

could guidry be the problem? absolutely

but everyone on here was *****ing about the offense last year and we got cam ward and damien Martinez and now we have the best offense in the country

need Mario to go ham in the portal on D

 

[Negro-Wan Kanobi]

Gonna search my post history before reacting to this

I do the same.

I've learned not to reply to hot takes because CIS prophecies come true and therefore, there shall be receipts.

 

[TRick72]

If we’re doing hypotheticals while longing for Manny’s players back, I think the better question is if you give Manny Man **** and this roster do we make the CFP??

 

[E1k]

We miss their leadership badly

 

[Squid Bumciorek]

Neither of those players were responsible for setting an edge so my guess is no.

 

[Roe 15th00]

The same two guys who the majority of the board wanted gone..CIS gonna CIS

 

[Cookie917]

its so hard playing with these hypotheticals but having 2 NFL players on the back end def would not hurt.

I was talking to a friend earlier and we wondered if our schedule was reversed, and we started the season with a loss to Syracuse and ended with a UF drubbing in the swamp if we are likely in. Late losses crush you when it comes to the committee and selections.

 

[lholtz52]

Absolutely. And that shows just how close we were. Now we need to go find their replacements but also somehow replace a Heisman level QB and our most productive slot receiver in program history. Make it happen Mario.

I am the one that disagrees.
Neither one played and followed their assignment on defense and made holes available for the runners/receivers.

 

[grover]

I am the one that disagrees.
Neither one played and followed their assignment on defense and made holes available for the runners/receivers.

Not arguing they did that at times. But did you see the aircraft carrier sized holes Powell and Harris made available?

 

[RangerGranger]

When I tell you.. it was PAIN not seeing Zaquan Patterson on the field. How can we not question Zaquan could be a bust? I can't pass judgement too soon, but dam man.

 

[grover]

When I tell you.. it was PAIN not seeing Zaquan Patterson on the field. How can we not question Zaquan could be a bust? I can't pass judgement too soon, but dam man.

Patterson made assignment mistakes when they put him in just like everyone else. I'm telling you, Guidry messed with their heads. Something is fundamentally broken back there. We need more talent. But that debacle was not about just talent, it was the dynamic.

Guidry may go somewhere else and tear it up, be the best **** DC in history. But IMO it's not happening here. He's gotta go.

 

[canemachine]

I love this place. Reminds me of Jaquan and Redwine. Love them, turn on them, and then love them again when they are gone

 

[RangerGranger]

Patterson made assignment mistakes when they put him in just like everyone else. I'm telling you, Guidry messed with their heads. Something is fundamentally broken back there. We need more talent. But that debacle was not about just talent, it was the dynamic.

Guidry may go somewhere else and tear it up, be the best **** DC in history. But IMO it's not happening here. He's gotta go.

I'm stuck in between us keeping him. I like him. But I know our production was *** and I'm 32 y/o. I need cash now.

 

[ToTheHouse]

Kam Kinchens was all around safety James would’ve bring physicality in the secondary which we lack heavily.

 

[Wake_Cane]

Then Guidry isn’t the problem.

The universe often permits you to have more than one problem at the same time, as it turns out.

 

[Bird4um]

The universe often permits you to have more than one problem at the same time, as it turns out.

Usually not correlated