forums

DT Ford says he's set to enroll Sunday

View as article
With today's tempo offensively, depth(and having the ability to rotate guys in and out) is more important than ever. If a guy can contribute legitimately in the 2-deep as a freshman, throw him out there. And with the risks of football being talked about more than ever, IMO, guy are trying to get to the league as quickly as possible(and then get to their second contract ASAP if they are good enough).

No need to waste a year if a guy can play..
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Highly doubtful both RJ and Norton come back next year. I hate that he came in late but so long as he's ready to play, he should. 2018 he will be needed early and often.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I can only see RS for qbs, because you can only have one at a time. We want our skill position players to think they are good enough to start as freshmen. For pretty much every other position, a skilled player should find a way into the rotation. As someone said (I think franchise) if a player is still on the team after five years it probably means he wasn't good enough to get drafted. If you RS a skill position player, he might actually only contribute two years. Might as well give a player live game experience in year 1, so he is more prepared to contribute in year 2 & 3.
 
Advertisement
The Franchise said:
rokulika said:
The Franchise said:
rokulika said:
"If he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway" isn't always the case.

Not that he should redshirt, but many of our best players have stayed for 4 or 5 years.
Click to expand...

He can still play 4 years without taking a RS. How many of our best players were here for 5 years?
Click to expand...

Only great 5th year senior that comes to mind immediately is Reed.

But the "if he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway" thing wasn't true more recently with Coley, Elder, Chad Thomas, Hurns. Most of the time it will be true (redshirting Lamar Miller, David Njoku was stupid) but I don't get the sense that Ford is good enough to be a 3 and out guy.
Click to expand...

I don't expect Ford to be a 3 and out guy either. But I don't expect him to play more than 4 years here either. It's incredibly rare these days for a kid with size and ability to spend 5 years at a university.

If Ford is still here in 5 years that most likely means he's terrible. And in that case they'd probably run him off before year 5 anyway.
Click to expand...

How the **** is he going to "play more than four years"? Stop posting for the sake of seeing your own posts.
 
RealDBC13 said:
The Franchise said:
rokulika said:
The Franchise said:
rokulika said:
"If he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway" isn't always the case.

Not that he should redshirt, but many of our best players have stayed for 4 or 5 years.
Click to expand...

He can still play 4 years without taking a RS. How many of our best players were here for 5 years?
Click to expand...

Only great 5th year senior that comes to mind immediately is Reed.

But the "if he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway" thing wasn't true more recently with Coley, Elder, Chad Thomas, Hurns. Most of the time it will be true (redshirting Lamar Miller, David Njoku was stupid) but I don't get the sense that Ford is good enough to be a 3 and out guy.
Click to expand...

I don't expect Ford to be a 3 and out guy either. But I don't expect him to play more than 4 years here either. It's incredibly rare these days for a kid with size and ability to spend 5 years at a university.

If Ford is still here in 5 years that most likely means he's terrible. And in that case they'd probably run him off before year 5 anyway.
Click to expand...

How the **** is he going to "play more than four years"? Stop posting for the sake of seeing your own posts.
Click to expand...

Someone needs a hug...

Go Canes!
 
Hypothetically a player could be on a college team for seven years, right? Year 1 Redshirt, Year 2 medical gray shirt, then still have 4 years of eligibility, and then can play as a grad transfer at another school year 7. Would that actually be possible?
 
TimeB0mb said:
Hypothetically a player could be on a college team for seven years, right? Year 1 Redshirt, Year 2 medical gray shirt, then still have 4 years of eligibility, and then can play as a grad transfer at another school year 7. Would that actually be possible?
Click to expand...

No. Grad transfer year is still one of the four years.
 
Advertisement
AdrianP said:
Redshirts are obsolete. This kid is going to be asked to start next year. Why waste him on the bench? Plain dumb. Kid needs game day experience now, not next year at lsu.
Click to expand...
I agree.. every snap he gets this year makes him that much better for next year when Big Big Mac and Super Ken move into the League

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
 
Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
 
UknowWhat said:
Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

You've seen recruiting from angle most of us never have, so Amen.
 
Advertisement
k9cane said:
With today's tempo offensively, depth(and having the ability to rotate guys in and out) is more important than ever. If a guy can contribute legitimately in the 2-deep as a freshman, throw him out there. And with the risks of football being talked about more than ever, IMO, guy are trying to get to the league as quickly as possible(and then get to their second contract ASAP if they are good enough).

No need to waste a year if a guy can play..
Click to expand...

I think the latest NFL labor agreement reduced the value of trying to be a higher round pick. Getting the that 2nd contract became a better value play. Now, being 1st or 2nd round still gives player some extra staying power because teams don't like to look like idiots for drafting them early and then cutting them, but for pure $$$ impact, the 2nd deal is the money play for most. Now, from the academic side, using that redshirt year to pound the books and overload credits toward grad day is a smart move. But speed guys and RB probably get gone in 3 anyway because of the tire ware and simple fact that legs go first. Not everyone can be OJ Anderson and go from great speed guy to great pound a grind guy at Super Bowl level.
 
UknowWhat said:
Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Not necessarily true. Fsu redshirted 2 high ranked D-lineman last year in cedric wood and janarius robinson. They turned around and got 2 5 star players at the same position this past class in kaindoh and wilson.

Ohio st. got one of the best d-lines in the country and they are deep. Their entire starting d-line was all redshirted and they have more guys who will redshirt this year likely and still is on track to sign maybe the best d-line class this cycle.
 
Advertisement
252cane said:
UknowWhat said:
Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Not necessarily true. Fsu redshirted 2 high ranked D-lineman last year in cedric wood and janarius robinson. They turned around and got 2 5 star players at the same position this past class in kaindoh and wilson.

Ohio st. got one of the best d-lines in the country and they are deep. Their entire starting d-line was all redshirted and they have more guys who will redshirt this year likely and still is on track to sign maybe the best d-line class this cycle.
Click to expand...



All true, but we don't have a salary cap like those schools, and you know good DTs are few and far between, so the going rate gets steep.
 
252cane said:
UknowWhat said:
Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Not necessarily true. Fsu redshirted 2 high ranked D-lineman last year in cedric wood and janarius robinson. They turned around and got 2 5 star players at the same position this past class in kaindoh and wilson.

Ohio st. got one of the best d-lines in the country and they are deep. Their entire starting d-line was all redshirted and they have more guys who will redshirt this year likely and still is on track to sign maybe the best d-line class this cycle.
Click to expand...

I'll take that... valid points ... Considering a RedShirt was Taboo for Shaq... He wanted to be on the field
 
Advertisement
Back
Top