forums

DAILY DEBATE: Who is the best returning player in the country not named Jeremiah Smith?

Advertisement
Advertisement
If using future draft potential, no chance Downs is top 5 as a Safety.

Qb, WR, Edge, maybe OT or CB

QB- manning/psu kid/maybe Beck
WR- Williams/Wingo
Edge- Simmons/Stewart

OT & CB no idea.
 
Advertisement
90scane said:
If using future draft potential, no chance Downs is top 5 as a Safety.

Qb, WR, Edge, maybe OT or CB

QB- manning/psu kid/maybe Beck
WR- Williams/Wingo
Edge- Simmons/Stewart

OT & CB no idea.
Click to expand...
Not yet...but suspect it will be Manning by October.

Hopefully destroys Florida 4 Oct.
 
Advertisement
NC_Canes_11 said:
Y’all spent months wacking it to Mateer and not a single person drops his name?
Click to expand...
Circumstances.

Mateer was the best option available given the circumstances & the Offensive fit. That's not mutually exclusive to being the best returning player.

He's a good QB, but Oklahoma is not projected to be a playoff team even with adding him. He'll make their Offense better, but he doesn't necessarily elevate them to contender status.

What last year & previous years have shown us, is in the playoff era having a good/great QB doesn't really mean much in the grand scheme of things.

The most important players to push your team over the edge to being playoff caliber, is Defensive catalysts & high valued Offensive skill players at WR & RB.

So when you look at the best returning players for the upcoming season, QB's are going to be in the 10-20 range mostly.
 
Memnon said:
Circumstances.

Mateer was the best option available given the circumstances & the Offensive fit. That's not mutually exclusive to being the best returning player.

He's a good QB, but Oklahoma is not projected to be a playoff team even with adding him. He'll make their Offense better, but he doesn't necessarily elevate them to contender status.

What last year & previous years have shown us, is in the playoff era having a good/great QB doesn't really mean much in the grand scheme of things.

The most important players to push your team over the edge to being playoff caliber, is Defensive catalysts & high valued Offensive skill players at WR & RB.

So when you look at the best returning players for the upcoming season, QB's are going to be in the 10-20 range mostly.
Click to expand...
Unless Arch lives up to the hype, next years QB class may be worse than this year. Even if he is great I doubt he declares the Mannings tend to maximize college eligibility.
 
90scane said:
If using future draft potential, no chance Downs is top 5 as a Safety.

Qb, WR, Edge, maybe OT or CB

QB- manning/psu kid/maybe Beck
WR- Williams/Wingo
Edge- Simmons/Stewart

OT & CB no idea.
Click to expand...
STOP with the NFL draft potential...thread was best returning player in the country not named Jeremiah Smith. People always have to interject NFL potential when that wasn't the question
 
Advertisement
IbzRlz said:
STOP with the NFL draft potential...thread was best returning player in the country not named Jeremiah Smith. People always have to interject NFL potential when that wasn't the question
Click to expand...
It isn’t like the list I gave you is dog****. I simply didn’t give you the best of every position. How about heisman votes? I have a feeling Downs won’t be in NYC.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top