Great question & I agree with you on Samuel!
To answer you though, I would make a bunch of changes.
First off, I'm not sure about the hire of Patke & Simpson. I would have hired at least 1 proven Ace Defensive recruiter after Rumph & Kool's failure to land elite targets late in the cycle last year. Hopefully, they work out though, but TBD.
Secondly, I would readjust Rumph's recruiting role. This could be done in a lot of ways. You could move him off primary for Broward or you get Hartley/Dugans involved on any elite DB or defensive recruit that we're going after etc. I also think Rumph needs to go to a couple sales seminar and check his ego at the door (e.g. his reaction to Henderson & reports that he's done with "divas"). These are not adults, these are kids - and you need a cool head to deal with them and expect diva behavior. The big reality though is we've now missed on our top DB targets 3 years in a row, so something has to change!