forums

Carson Beck

Advertisement
canesbrah said:
What’s up with his injury though?
Click to expand...
the sopranos hbo GIF
 
pacusmc said:
CIS SAYS HE SUCKS!!
2023 season 3900 yard season 24-6
Avg 9.4 yards. I’m not an evaluator to say he’s great.
But no way he sucks.

Click to expand...

He doesn’t suck but he’s had some atrocious games. UF being one. He’s a pretty good to good college qb. Nothing special or elite. Just surround him with talent and a defense we’ll be fine. He won’t need to be Cam.
 
Advertisement
Roscoe627 said:
Fernando’s grandfather passed away years ago unfortunately. So I sincerely doubt that was the source. And if that Mendoza belongs to “the large Gables clan” than he is at least a distant cousin of Fernando the QB. I’ll call BS considering the impossibility of said sources being real.
Click to expand...
Doesn’t share the same last name. Mendoza’s grandparents on his mother’s side are both alive.
 
DTP said:
The weird TVD comparisons are off base too. Yes, 12 interceptions is too many for what should have been an “elite” quarterback. 11 of them were in a four game stretch so that’s ugly. But if you look at his overall performances during those games, he really only had one garbage game and it was against Texas. He had a 3 pick game against Alabama where he threw for 440 yards and 3 touchdowns also. He had a 2 pick game against Mississippi State but he also completed 75% of his passes for 460 yards and 3 touchdowns. He had another three pick game against Florida where he completed 63% of his passes, threw for over 300 yards and had two touchdowns.

So during the four game stretch where he threw all but one of his season total of interceptions, his team went 3-1 and only had one ineffective game. This isn’t TVD struggling to complete simple passes against Virginia and North Carolina State. This was more of a case of a dude probably getting a bit overconfident and trying to do too much by forcing some bad throws. He also didn’t throw a single pick during his last four starts so it’s not like he fell into some kind of turnover funk and never regained control again. It’s also a dude who only threw 6 picks in 417 attempts in 2023 so there’s a pretty good sample size.
Click to expand...
I watched some analysis of one of his Alabama picks. Beck changed the play and one receiver messed up the audible. It was 100% on the receiver.
 
Cribby said:
He doesn’t suck but he’s had some atrocious games. UF being one. He’s a pretty good to good college qb. Nothing special or elite. Just surround him with talent and a defense we’ll be fine. He won’t need to be Cam.
Click to expand...
Also, huge plus is he’s played in some very big games and tough environments. I know some lament missing Mendoza (and I agree) but as long as we get something closer to 2023 Beck, I think his experience is a huge plus given our schedule next year.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
DTP said:
The weird TVD comparisons are off base too. Yes, 12 interceptions is too many for what should have been an “elite” quarterback. 11 of them were in a four game stretch so that’s ugly. But if you look at his overall performances during those games, he really only had one garbage game and it was against Texas. He had a 3 pick game against Alabama where he threw for 440 yards and 3 touchdowns also. He had a 2 pick game against Mississippi State but he also completed 75% of his passes for 460 yards and 3 touchdowns. He had another three pick game against Florida where he completed 63% of his passes, threw for over 300 yards and had two touchdowns.

So during the four game stretch where he threw all but one of his season total of interceptions, his team went 3-1 and only had one ineffective game. This isn’t TVD struggling to complete simple passes against Virginia and North Carolina State. This was more of a case of a dude probably getting a bit overconfident and trying to do too much by forcing some bad throws. He also didn’t throw a single pick during his last four starts so it’s not like he fell into some kind of turnover funk and never regained control again. It’s also a dude who only threw 6 picks in 417 attempts in 2023 so there’s a pretty good sample size.
Click to expand...
If I remember correctly some of those picks were tipped by his receivers as well.
 
Advertisement
Cribby said:
He doesn’t suck but he’s had some atrocious games. UF being one. He’s a pretty good to good college qb. Nothing special or elite. Just surround him with talent and a defense we’ll be fine. He won’t need to be Cam.
Click to expand...

Might make a better NFL QB then college
 
Advertisement
Back
Top