Carson Beck vs Quinn Ewers

[canes1996]

People acting like food critics while starving. Hilarious.

 

[mr.h]

Transfer Portal: Carson Beck Reportedly Offered $6.5M & Nico Iamaleava Rumors Point Them to One College.​

Could be an SEC team?

 

[simplycanes]

 

[ScubaCane]

Neither if the cost is $5 mil

I don't get this, is it your money? Do you want to go into the season with Kirby, I mean Emory starting?

 

[Silver King]

People acting like food critics while starving. Hilarious.

Best line about Canes Fans of 2025 so far!

 

[Clipse]

All I know is Ewers has much better receivers, OL, running game and especially play calling than Beck and has basically the same numbers despite Beck having Mike Bobo and leading the country in dropped yards from receivers. I think Ewers has better tools, but he's never put it all together.

 

[ajkreider]

People on here act like there's a bottomless pit of money. Boosters paying big money for non-performing players makes them less likely to contribute next year and the year after that. Even the very rich don't like wasting money

 

[CoastCane]

Neither if the cost is $5 mil

spend 10mil if it means he's better than Emory. My canes connective should cover at least a couple of hours of his pay.

 

[Memnon]

Not a fan of either one tbh.

But if both become available, take Ewers.

 

[KANE]

MID vs MID but both miles better then what we have currently on the roster

Yeah... Mid is wayyy better than Reggie.

 

[canadianhurricane]

Beck

He's had to do more with less his entire career. Beck has never had the support the Ewers has (consistent NFL bound WRs, great OL, great Running game, great OC/HC). This year, Beck had no one the throw to, and a terrible OC.

Ewers has always had one of the best play callers/designer and a solid OL. And still, he didn't have the type of year that would get him drafted where he wants, hence he'll probably be in the portal. Besides maybe Oregon, Ewers will have less the work with than when he was at Texas.

Beck, on the other hand, will benefit from getting away from UGA and BOBOs 90s offense. For example, at UM, he'd undoubtedly have a better OL and OC to work with.

If we have a choice, I'm riding with Beck, just as long as he can come back 100% healthy

 

[canes23]

Not a fan of either one tbh.

But if both become available, take Ewers.

Honest question: why Ewers over Beck? Is it the injury?
And follow up…would you take Beck at all?

Thanks brother!

 

[Supacane954]

If he wants anything over 3 mil give me Luke Nickel for the low and let’s watch him grow in this offense

 

[Tony4Canes]

 

[TheATLCane]

Beck over Ewers. Neither are Cam Ward

 

[Gennaker Cane]

People acting like food critics while starving. Hilarious.

This, perfect analogy.
For those finding fault with Beck- you're saying no to an experienced, successful QB who has his flaws, different flaws but similar package as the guy we just brought in, that undeniably works for us. And Emory has a huge heart, but so did Jacurri. Love them both but at least acknowledge that we do want to win, don't we?

 

[IamaCane4Life]

Well Beck is the QB!

 

[IamaCane4Life]

Beck over Ewers. Neither are Cam Ward

Yeah, is this suppose to be something mind blowing! Beck is better that Emory, Mendoza, and any other WB not named Mateer!

 

[mcnaire2004]

Beck committed. Still hope we go after Quinn

 

[Brickell]

Beck, because Ewers has less excuses. Ewers has Sark, an elite OL, and elite skill players, and yet is mid. Bobo was Beck’s OC, and UGA was depending on Colbie Young as an elite WR lol.

Bobo sucks, and UGA fans want him run out of town. Dawson can work with Beck.