Carson Beck vs Quinn Ewers

[Supacane954]

Who would you Guys Like to have!? Both will most likely be available in the coming days!? I’m leaning towards Quinn.

 

[skyman]

I like Ewers better but he not on market right now. Before his injury he was playing at heisman race level.. But both our better than what we have so we will rock with either.

 

[PIPO]

Ewers over Beck, however, Mario can’t **** around. Take the first one to want in.

 

[Da Jumbo Mutombo]

Ewers > Beck.

Ewers is NFL tho.

 

[Andrew]

Ewers

 

[Hold My Beer]

Who would you Guys Like to have!? Both will most likely be available in the coming days!? I’m leaning towards Quinn.

The comparison I'm wondering about is does Ewers drink more beer or does Beck smoke more weed?

That's the vibe I get from these two tbh. Basically they come across as:

If Beck wasn't coming off a serious injury, I'd probably be more excited about him since he's from North Florida

 

[ajkreider]

Neither if the cost is $5 mil

 

[DC3]

I think Texas beats OSU tomorrow and that takes Ewers out of the running.

Beck is the only choice

 

[Hold My Beer]

I think Texas beats OSU tomorrow

Let's hope so

 

[Miami[]_[]Smoke]

Ewers by a mile. Beck turned the ball over way too much and was not effective in some games. Beck is another TVD roller coaster ride

 

[Stylie]

Assuming Beck comes here, I’d say Ewers to Bama if he goes portal.

 

[Trav]

Neither if the cost is $5 mil

Dude you're kidding yourself. That's the market for a high profile QB right now. If you're worried about money stick with Emory or try another FCS guy like Poff. Does that sound appealing?

 

[Shooter McGavin]

The guy who isn’t currently shelved with a major injury

 

[ajkreider]

I'd rather run with Fickel, and 5 $1 million o-lineman.

 

[HicksFix]

I think Texas beats OSU tomorrow and that takes Ewers out of the running.

Beck is the only choice

Idk man. The way OSU is playing right now they will be hard to beat. You could be right though.

 

[Golsen82]

Ewers over Beck, however, Mario can’t **** around. Take the first one to want in.

Beck good enough for a bridge qb. Played big games so I feel better going against ND with him

 

[Golsen82]

Assuming Beck comes here, I’d say Ewers to Bama if he goes portal.

Or back to OSU

 

[Tony4Canes]

I’d imagine decision will happen Saturday after seeing who wins tomorrow

I think if Texas loses, Ewers hits Portal

 

[Canes_N_Cats]

Ewers, but keep in mind he looked pedestrian much of the year and is basically getting pushed out despite having an elite playcaller. Beck has had a below average OC. I also think Beck is mentally tougher than Ewers.

That being said, people need to calm their **** over Beck. Certainly a big upgrade over our current roster, which is a godsend given how things were looking, but dude was very meh once his NFL rookie record setting TE and top 11 producing WR left.

In SEC play, he had 12 TDs vs 12 INTs. I would expect him to be better than that but he is going to disappoint so many homer fans. I would anticipate a 3,500 yds/ 30 TD/ 10 INT type season

 

[NZ Cane]

I’d take the guy without Tommy John scar on his throwing arm.

Didn't have Tommy John...but agree with your point.