I agree with you, to a point. Horton produced this year, but, he was a one-trick pony. I get the experience factor you speak of and I agree it is important, but that can easily be overcome in the portal. I would venture to guess that there is no shortage of WR's in the portal that give you more threats and perhaps even the same short slant **** for way less money if this happens to be a cash grab by Horton. This is why I seriously don't get the outrage on here. I guess its par for the course with this fanbase always *****ing about something.
I absolutely agree with you that a QB portal grab would get the juices flowing. Whether that be a young stud with years left that can come in and compete (ex. Mendoza, Nolan, etc) or a splashy 1-year rental in Mateer. I'm stoked about Luke Nickel and happen to think he is the future, kid has moxie galore. Nickel reminds me alot of a young Dorsey. Regardless of who is behind center next year, you can't ignore the fact that he will be behind a very good O Line with a strong RB room. With Dawson's scheme juices flowing from this year, I'm not worried one bit about the QB position (just me). I would rather this staff fix the MAJOR problems on the backend of the defense which is way more in need of an overhaul than the offense.
My take is that if we can have a solid offense (Top 25) and a solid defense (Top 25), we can easily win 10 or more games next year. We don't have to have the #1 offense or vice versa. We need to be more well-rounded across the roster, especially defense. Just get me stud DB's and a legitimate DT and we should be fine.
Just my take.