Who Would You Rather Have?

[407cane]

Retarded. OL and DL win ships. A great DL makes every position on D look better.

2 five star corners are better than a very good DT and a pretty good DE

Campbell and Surtain would look great playing behind 4 Ryan Fines, I'm sure.

and nesta would be great playing in front of 3 nate dortch's and 2 robert knowles

whats your point

I hope you're trying to be this dense.

I don't know how anyone reading this conversation would consider me the dense one

it's not like we're saying nesta and chatfield are terrible and we don't want them, OP asked which would people rather. We came up with a solid answer, you said it was retarded and you're only defense was "ryan fines" who won't ever see playing time.

two elite talents > a great talent and chatfield who may or may not ever start for us. It's all opinion based

 

[Dwinstitles]

We need them all, we need nesta we need PS2 because of Jobe but even wit JJ hes a talent u have to take, we need TC, we need Chatfield.

 

[Tad Footeball]

Who would you rather, Carmen Electra or Pam Anderson, but...they both have a yeast infection

And Hepatitis.

 

[hesskilla]

We need them all, we need nesta we need PS2 because of Jobe but even wit JJ hes a talent u have to take, we need TC, we need Chatfield.

We don't NEED them all.

We need Nesta + CB.

That's the combination that makes this such a good question by OP.

 

[JgDaCane]

None, happy with Miller & Bethel. On to 2019.

 

[Lexcane]

We need them all, we need nesta we need PS2 because of Jobe but even wit JJ hes a talent u have to take, we need TC, we need Chatfield.

We don't NEED them all.

We need Nesta + CB.

That's the combination that makes this such a good question by OP.

Yes this is exactly right. Nesta is the most important obviously. A DT class of him, Miller, and Odenigbo is top notch. We have a ton of CB talent coming in so it's not critical to get PS or TC but it sure would be nice to get at least one of them, just to shove it in the face of Saban or Smart and let them know we ain't ****ting around no more. I like Chatfield a lot - i think DE is a bigger need than DT, esp since Chatman will grown into a DT eventually.

In order of priority: Nesta, CB, Chatfield, CB

 

[OriginalCanesCanesCanes]

I hate hypotheticals that have zero basis in reality.

There will never an opportunity where we get to choose what player we get to have on the team. So what’s the point? I don’t get it.

We have room for all four so it’s not realistic. Why even bother thinking about it.

 

[Canes1968]

Nesta over all others...no question.

 

[marshallrc13]

All 4 is who I want. Surtains and Campbells don't grow on trees though so....

 

[Gatorhater]

Nesta and anyone. Miami has to have great DTs, period. The are harder to find than cbs. The two CBS would help recruiting class rank more but the DTs in this class will be what gets us to the playoffs or not.

 

[MIA42178]

Anya Ivy
and
Romi Rain

Oh, thought this was a pornstar thread then realized I’m not on WEZ
Peace out fay-gits

/ OP shops for shae butter sales on Sundays

 

[Hurricanemike32]

Agree.

Two shut down CB's are more valuable.

Retarded. OL and DL win ships. A great DL makes every position on D look better.

2 five star corners are better than a very good DT and a pretty good DE

Campbell and Surtain would look great playing behind 4 Ryan Fines, I'm sure.

and nesta would be great playing in front of 3 nate dortch's and 2 robert knowles

whats your point

You must've missed the early signing day. I don't recall seeing any Nate Dortch's or Bob Knowles sign on the dotted line that day. Ivey, Blades, Hall, and Frierson were all very much sought after players.

 

[Hurricanemike32]

We need them all, we need nesta we need PS2 because of Jobe but even wit JJ hes a talent u have to take, we need TC, we need Chatfield.

We don't NEED them all.

We need Nesta + CB.

That's the combination that makes this such a good question by OP.

Yes this is exactly right. Nesta is the most important obviously. A DT class of him, Miller, and Odenigbo is top notch. We have a ton of CB talent coming in so it's not critical to get PS or TC but it sure would be nice to get at least one of them, just to shove it in the face of Saban or Smart and let them know we ain't ****ting around no more. I like Chatfield a lot - i think DE is a bigger need than DT, esp since Chatman will grown into a DT eventually.

In order of priority: Nesta, CB, Chatfield, CB

I think that calling that DT class top notch is taking it a little too far....just my opinion.

 

[Hemsleysalmons]

Strong possibility Surtain chooses lsu and Campbell Georgia. Not my opinion, but national media and national recruiting blogs have stated this. I hope they are wrong. Go Canes.

 

[Gi0logy]

2 five star corners are better than a very good DT and a pretty good DE

Campbell and Surtain would look great playing behind 4 Ryan Fines, I'm sure.

and nesta would be great playing in front of 3 nate dortch's and 2 robert knowles

whats your point

I hope you're trying to be this dense.

I don't know how anyone reading this conversation would consider me the dense one

it's not like we're saying nesta and chatfield are terrible and we don't want them, OP asked which would people rather. We came up with a solid answer, you said it was retarded and you're only defense was "ryan fines" who won't ever see playing time.

two elite talents > a great talent and chatfield who may or may not ever start for us. It's all opinion based

I think he’s saying you’re dense because the CB depth/talent looks a little better than DT depth/talent. He brings up Fines because if we don’t get Nesta then Kool has little to work with. I still think Kool will find a way but you need Nesta.

Also, Nesta is an elite talent. Not great. Don’t get it twisted.

 

[ACE01]

Need PS2, Campbell, and Nesta just to prove a point that we can keep the top guys home.

 

[404CANES]

None, happy with Miller & Bethel. On to 2019.

And that's how we return to being elite for you?... You settling, like Folden did for 4 yrs. At minimum, Nesta and any one of the CBs would solidify this class. I will be ecstatic to have them all. But to say we're good w/out neither pairing is borderline insane.

 

[Ivan The Terrible]

We need pressure on the opposing QB first and foremost gottdammit so if we have to play OP’s bs game we have to choose Nesta in any scenario. That Nesta and Miller combo is going to be unstoppable!

 

[404CANES]

Strong possibility Surtain chooses lsu and Campbell Georgia. Not my opinion, but national media and national recruiting blogs have stated this. I hope they are wrong. Go Canes.

Question...how much time do you think the national media or recruiting blogs spend with any recruit.?... So why do ppl give them so much accreditation for knowing which way a recruit will go, specifically with these AH boys who have kept their decision quiet and in-house as can be

 

[NJshoreCane]

Who would you rather, Carmen Electra or Pam Anderson, but...they both have a yeast infection

All 4.