I think Swasey sucks.
HOWEVER, Golden is basically overseeing S&C now. He's talked about it a couple different times. I think back when he was hired, he said something about how S&C would be tailored to his expectations. And a couple weeks ago, he said it's going to take another year of S&C to get guys where he wants them physically.
Swasey is competent enough to execute Golden's plan. I think the problem under Coker and Shannon was that Swasey oversaw everything, and he wasn't suited for it, IMO.
I get what you are saying, but Golden isn't a S&C coach either. There is no reason why the U can't bring in one of the top S&C coaches out there. Where is Decker? This shouldn't even be on Golden's plate.
This is the crux of things. Golden's not an S/C coach. The idea that Golden is running S/C is ludicrous--and if he's actually trying to then he's ludicrous. We can only surmise that Golden thinks Swasey is good enough to do this job provided that the expectations of the program are good enough. Golden has no formal S/C training as far as I can tell it so the idea that he runs the program while often proferred seems bizarre.
Beyond that, S/C was not responsible for this game. What was responsible was a lack of preparation and intensity. These guys are big and strong enough to handle USF just like they did 2 years ago. There's no conceivable way that our line can do a sufficient job against FSU (which they basically did) or an OSU but can't handle this team. Neglecting Swasey, the issue this game was one of motivation/preparation IMO. We can't just blame whatever coach we don't like from week to week. Were Shannon coaching this game, I can tell you that there wouldn't be much discussion of Swasey moreso the effort.
Couple of things with your comments. I don't think it is prep unless you want to say it has been an issue all year on short yardage. That is scheme/technique/strength. I saw several times when our oline was owned at the point of attack against Bethune, Oshwo, UVA. and all day yesterday. The thing I can't understand and don't have an answer for is I've seen Gunn knocked back, and even knocked on his *** in short yardage when he knows the count and it is a short yardage running play. Is there something we are missing that the D is keying on game to game? I just don't know, but I know it is happening.
I also think it is partially S&C, as well as technique. That obviously falls on Kehoe.
And the last comment is just flat wrong. Swasey has been getting called out since 05 and possible earlier from this group. The only thing related to Shannon as a comment has been that he protected him.