We were 8-4 at this time last year. We were 9-4 in 2013. So we've been in the exact same place 2 of the last 3 years previous to Richt.
I can see both arguments for this season being positive or negative. But to me it just feels like we're in the same place we've been for the last 10+ seasons - a 7 to 9 win team with hope for the future.
It's true that the record is what matters the most. However, can you really say that this year's team is no better than last year's? All 8 win teams are not equal. I mean Pitt and Georgia Tech are eight win teams. The truth is, Miami improved in almost every single area compared to last season. Now, those improvements have to eventually translate into wins but in the interim, you can't compare this team to last year's team or the 2013 team at all. I'm confident that the 2016 Hurricanes would smoke the 2015 and 2013 versions of the team.
Like I said, I can see the optimistic side of the argument. To me the defense got much better, the offense underachieved, and the record stayed the same. This season felt more like treading water than making significant improvement.
And a healthy 2013 team was better than the 2015 & 2016 teams IMO. They just got unlucky with injuries.
Then you did not watch. In practically every metric save record, there was significant improvement, and not just on D, where it was AMAZING progress. This is a different football team top to bottom that IMPROVED at the end of the year. We've not seen a UM team run the last 4 since 2006.
WAKE UP Gator, pay attention or get lost. Fuggin people.
The improvement on defense was great, no question. But with basically the entire offense returning, and with Richt calling plays, a bigger improvement on Offense was expected. Statistically they may have been better, but they just looked bad for all of October. I did watch the games, and what I saw was less than I had expected.
The Pitt game was a good win. But for me, the way we looked against the bad teams at the end of our season, UVA-NC St.-Duke, doesn't erase my memory of how we looked against FSU-UNC-VT-ND. We looked great at the start of the season playing weaker teams, and we looked great at the end of the season playing weaker teams. How we look against quality teams is more of a measuring stick for me.
If we look good against West Virginia and finish strong in recruiting I'll be much more optimistic for next year, but I'm more cautious about my enthusiasm until that happens.