Portal QB Wishlist

The issue is that for some reason, people aren't capable of realizing that multiple things can be true at once. For example, TVD was absolutely a problem for a majority of the year, also, Mario has made some absolutely mind blowing mistakes during games, including one that literally cost us a win, and also Dawson's play calling for long stretches lacked any sort of creativity and hamstrung our offense.

It's not a 1 or the other type of thing. All of those things came together and produced the season we just had. However, if we are ranking them in terms of what were the worst issues:

1. TVD Play- just a walking interception/turnover machine. The turnovers are all on him, not going to blame the coaches for him staring down his receivers and not understanding how to beat zone coverage. Even slightly below average QB play instead of the abortion he put out against NCST and GT and we win those games.

2. Mario Game Day Coaching- We simply cannot be making the types of mistakes he has been making regularly when you are being paid $8mill+ per year. It just can't happen. He needs to embrace the fact the he's not the smartest guy in the room and let his coordinators do what we pay them to do. If he could ever just focus on recruiting and stay out of the way on game day, we could make some real noise.

3. Dawson Playcalling- I am leaning more towards giving him a pass on this. I just can't believe the performance we saw against A&M was within his capability to then just reverse course and go vanilla the rest of the year without it being for one of two reasons. 1 is knowing how badly TVD was playing, he dumbed down the offense and decided to go more vanilla because of it. 2 is that Mario was dipping his hands into the offensive cookie jar and was hampering Dawson's playcalling. Either way, I saw enough good from him at times to give this a bit more time.
You’re not going to blame coaches for their QB not knowing how to beat coverage? What? What coverage in particular did he struggle against?

Any competent OC has at least 5 plays to “beat” each type of coverage. Or you do motion like they did against BC to help the QB identify the coverage or see that it is man.
 
Advertisement
Didn’t realize you were in the locker room and witnessed his leadership style first hand and got to experience his intangibles in action.

Throughout the season TVD was sent to Pasture by this fan base when it’s clear our issues go well beyond him
Didn’t realize you spoke first-hand with the coaches to gain insight into their communication strategy and how they can manipulate the fan base into thinking TVD is solely responsible for our underwhelming season.

Coaches make mistakes. Players make mistakes. Both can underperform. They are not mutually exclusive.
 
All three things were a problem, but this fan base is running with the narrative that TVd was THE problem when for me he is easily third in line for the problems you listed. That’s being scapegoated. As Cribby has said it was mutual for him to leave.
Ppl *****ed at Mario all year
Ppl *****ed at Dawson since GT

It seems like you're conveniently downplaying it so you can white knight for TVD
 
Didn’t realize you spoke first-hand with the coaches to gain insight into their communication strategy and how they can manipulate the fan base into thinking TVD is solely responsible for our underwhelming season.

Coaches make mistakes. Players make mistakes. Both can underperform. They are not mutually exclusive.
I didn’t. Never said I did, but this board clearly ran with the TVD is the main reason we are 7-5 narrative. Could just ljsten to a press conference where Mario shoots down any question that challenges him and refused to take any accountability

The point being, this board thinks TVd was our main issue and we are going to be in this same position next year hating the QB unless Dawson coaches like he did against BC and Mario actually learns how to manage a game.
 
Advertisement
Ppl *****ed at Mario all year
Ppl *****ed at Dawson since GT

It seems like you're conveniently downplaying it so you can white knight for TVD
This board has significantly *****ed about TVD 10 times more than Mario and Dawson.

Im not downplaying that TVD played with injuries and played poorly for four games there, but the real issues were how Mario and DAwson let the team down. You can change the QB…just don’t be surprised we are back here doing the same thing next year
 
This board has significantly *****ed about TVD 10 times more than Mario and Dawson.

Im not downplaying that TVD played with injuries and played poorly for four games there, but the real issues were how Mario and DAwson let the team down. You can change the QB…just don’t be surprised we are back here doing the same thing next year
This isn’t true in the slightest.
 
You’re not going to blame coaches for their QB not knowing how to beat coverage? What? What coverage in particular did he struggle against?

Any competent OC has at least 5 plays to “beat” each type of coverage. Or you do motion like they did against BC to help the QB identify the coverage or see that it is man.
You can call every type of 'beater coverage" you want, won't matter if your qb is 2 seconds late on the read and still tries to force throws or doesn't see lurking LBs and safeties. You can tell your QB EXACTLY what to do and how to do it..... but it's on them to get the ball out on time and accurately. That's TVD's biggest issue and not something you can blame Dawson or Mario for.
 
Advertisement
This board has significantly *****ed about TVD 10 times more than Mario and Dawson.

Im not downplaying that TVD played with injuries and played poorly for four games there, but the real issues were how Mario and DAwson let the team down. You can change the QB…just don’t be surprised we are back here doing the same thing next year
You got it cuz
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Back
Top