In fairness, let's stop acting like Coach L was John Wooden. Coach L has one Final Four, 1 Elite 8 and 2 Sweet 16 in his 14 years at Miami.
Miami went to the NCAA tournament 6 times under Coach L with the first trip largely because of Frank Haith recruits.
Coach L tenure looks really good because everyone else was really bad.
Coach L is the below average looking woman in a beauty pageant full of ugly women.
A lot of this "conventional wisdom" you want to use to hire a good mid major coach is promoting a rethread with a proven resume that says he is not what you want.
There are a lot of good X and I coaches but without talent, they become good assistant coaches.
If Jai Lucas is Leonard Hamilton all over again, that is not a bad thing. Hamilton made Coral Gables a destination. Sadly, the previous ADs kept giving the job to coaches who wanted one last check before they retire in South Florida.
What Jai is missing in Xs and Os, he will hire an offensive minded assistant coach along with a former HC to build on what he lacks.
The biggest difference is the guy who is good with Xs and Os cannot match what Jai does on the recruiting trail.
Xs and Os are important but without talent, it will not work!