Walsh 100% with this year's squad. Last year's squad, I'd probably go with Testaverde, because when it wasn't a bowl game, Vinny was dominant in reg season games and could gain a lot of yards with his legs as well as his arm.
With last year's OL and WR's dropping balls, Walsh would not be a good pick.
But, there isn't a Cane QB I'd rather have if the OL is decent and the WR's are actually catching the ball (which I believe we'll see big improvements on this year), than Steve Walsh. Ice in his veins, sharp mind and the very definition of a gamer. The only game he ever lost was stolen by an unscrupulous ref on a bad call, on the road, against the eventual undefeated #1 team and National Champion that year. That game was stolen.
Anyhoo, if there's talent to protect and to catch, in other words, no need for the QB's legs to add to the overall yardage, there's never been anyone better than Steve Walsh. He still hasn't lost a game as a Cane as far as I'm concerned. He's had one stolen, but he never lost one.