Not sure what you're "shaking your head" about?
I amended to add Brevin. That was my oversight. Brevin and DJ are currently "elite players in the ACC" like the original poster mentioned. Pinckney is playing decent. Nobody else is playing an at elite level.
Some of the guys you mentioned have potential (Garvin, Rousseau, Harvey) but haven't been "elite" and the rest of the guys you said are having subpar years and are NOT amongst the elite of the ACC let alone the country. Some barely get any burn (Hightower, Pope).
Hall looks lost out there.
Saban makes plenty of mistakes BTW he just recruits four 4/5* guys at every position so when he makes a mistake nobody notices.