Yes If you put them both on Miami's roster today, and went out to practice my belief is that Innis would immediately make plays. You could line him up anywhere on the field and he would make plays. Hykeem would look the part, you not see him make many plays, then all of a sudden he catches a deep ball that makes you see all that potential.
Innis could start at Miami right now, today. Hykeem could not. Now if you told me in 4 years Hykeem harnessed his natural ability, and really developed the skills at the WR position to put him as a first round pick, I wouldn't be surprised.