forums

How many Stars do the Starters Have

Novacane32000

Novacane32000

Sophomore
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,990
I know the star rating has been argued back and forth and I hope we are the exception but championship teams will typically have more than half the roster as 4/5 Star players. We are at 41%, though the last 2 CMR classes are 55%, so trending the right way.

As it stands right now 10 of our 22 starters will have 4 +stars (We may add a couple with the 2018 class)

Defense-Bandy, MJack, JJack, Willis, Shaq (I used Rivals so Jaquan is 3 stars on that site)
Offense-Tyree STL,Donaldson,AR,JT,Cager

We are close but need to stay on a roll recruiting wise to play with the big boys.
 

Advertisement
Here is offense based on 247 ranking (not composite)
We avg at 90.45 which would be a low 4* on 247. Good news is, when avg the backups at the weakest spots (QB and OL) the avg would go up bad news is they're young. Gotta continue to build the oline with blue chip prospects, coach up some projects, and find a QB

6/11 4*(+) 54%
*my guess at projected starting lineup game 1

QB: Rosier- 3* (83)
RB: Homer- 4* (93)
WR: Richards- 4* (94), Cager- 4* (94), Jeff Thomas- 4* (96)
TE: Jordan- 4* (95)
LT: Tyree St. Louis- 3* (87)
LG: Hayden Mahoney- 3* (84)
C: Tyler Gauthier- 3* (86)
RG: Venzell Boulware- 3* (88)
RT: Navaughn Donaldson- 4* (95)
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Novacane32000 said:
I know the star rating has been argued back and forth and I hope we are the exception but championship teams will typically have more than half the roster as 4/5 Star players. We are at 41%, though the last 2 CMR classes are 55%, so trending the right way.

As it stands right now 10 of our 22 starters will have 4 +stars (We may add a couple with the 2018 class)

Defense-Bandy, MJack, JJack, Willis, Shaq (I used Rivals so Jaquan is 3 stars on that site)
Offense-Tyree STL,Donaldson,AR,JT,Cager

We are close but need to stay on a roll recruiting wise to play with the big boys.
Click to expand...
Why are people keep talking about stars out coaches get players that fit our system go look at rivals and see how many 5 stars fsu had that didn't work out stop with the star thing go look at the games and stop looking at highlights tapes yall people kill me with the bs on size and all of that ever year fsu have ha a 5 star that did nothing go look on rivals and go back 10 years until now
 
Defense actually avg the exact same 90.45 as offense. obviously some of these are different MJ is def playing better than an 88, no way we can consider Willis a 98 at this point but this is based strictly off recruiting rank.

5/11 4*(+) 45%

DE: J. Jackson- 4* (94)
DT: Willis- 5* (98)
DT: Bethel- 3* (87)
DE: D. Jackson 4* (90)
Striker: Finley- 3* (87)
LB: Quarterman- 4* (93)
LB: Pickney- 3* (89)
CB: MJ- 3* (88)
FS: Redwine- 3* (88)
SS: Jaquan Johnson- 4* (93)
CB: Bandy- 3* (88)
 
cooperb23583 said:
Why are people keep talking about stars out coaches get players that fit our system go look at rivals and see how many 5 stars fsu had that didn't work out stop with the star thing go look at the games and stop looking at highlights tapes yall people kill me with the bs on size and all of that ever year fsu have ha a 5 star that did nothing go look on rivals and go back 10 years until now
Click to expand...

All of those 5 stars led Jimbo to 3 ACC championships, 1 Natty, 1 Atlantic championship 6 10+ win seasons in 8 years. They had 1 bad year and that was because Jimbo checked out and just off talent alone they ended up 7-6. Just off talent alone they almost beat us and took us to the last minute of the game. All of those 5 stars is the reason for that. A way higher percentage of 5 stars work out compared to 3 stars. That is a fact. Go look it up.
 
OriginalGatorHater said:
All of those 5 stars led Jimbo to 3 ACC championships, 1 Natty, 1 Atlantic championship 6 10+ win seasons in 8 years. They had 1 bad year and that was because Jimbo checked out and just off talent alone they ended up 7-6. Just off talent alone they almost beat us and took us to the last minute of the game. All of those 5 stars is the reason for that. A way higher percentage of 5 stars work out compared to 3 stars. That is a fact. Go look it up.
Click to expand...
Half of the 5 stars that was at fsu did nothing and u go look it up and it will show u James wilder nothing karlos Williams nothing Freeman wasnt a 5 star and had a great season yall to crazy to look go look it up and see none of the 5 stars did nothing for them a hand full maybe 2009 Greg Reid j mccdainles nothing I can keep going I'm starting facts
 
Advertisement
cooperb23583 said:
Half of the 5 stars that was at fsu did nothing and u go look it up and it will show u James wilder nothing karlos Williams nothing Freeman wasnt a 5 star and had a great season yall to crazy to look go look it up and see none of the 5 stars did nothing for them a hand full maybe 2009 Greg Reid j mccdainles nothing I can keep going I'm starting facts
Click to expand...

You aren't stating facts. You are picking out a few names that fits your agenda. Derwin James, Josh Sweat, and Dalvin Cook all balled out for them the last 2 years. No team wins Nattys without a bunch of 5 stars. About 90% of 5 stars end up making a team. 6.5% of 3 stars end up making an NFL roster.
 
2Focusd804 said:
Here is offense based on 247 ranking (not composite)
We avg at 90.45 which would be a low 4* on 247. Good news is, when avg the backups at the weakest spots (QB and OL) the avg would go up bad news is they're young. Gotta continue to build the oline with blue chip prospects, coach up some projects, and find a QB

6/11 4*(+) 54%
*my guess at projected starting lineup game 1

QB: Rosier- 3* (83)
RB: Homer- 4* (93)
WR: Richards- 4* (94), Cager- 4* (94), Jeff Thomas- 4* (96)
TE: Jordan- 4* (95)
LT: Tyree St. Louis- 3* (87)
LG: Hayden Mahoney- 3* (84)
C: Tyler Gauthier- 3* (86)
RG: Venzell Boulware- 3* (88)
RT: Navaughn Donaldson- 4* (95)
Click to expand...

That OL and QB won’t win any championships. We must improve there next year.
 
OriginalGatorHater said:
You aren't stating facts. You are picking out a few names that fits your agenda. Derwin James, Josh Sweat, and Dalvin Cook all balled out for them the last 2 years. No team wins Nattys without a bunch of 5 stars. About 90% of 5 stars end up making a team. 6.5% of 3 stars end up making an NFL roster.
Click to expand...
Lol josh sweat really this dude did nothing for fsu nothing think about all of the good de they had he wouldn't even play for Mickey ... james lol 1 good year freshman year jJ had better stats then him and he didn't get a invite to the awards show but he did lol james was trash last year could not jJ jock strap dalvin cook was a beast also he from dade and I'm sure that he was a 4 star coming out check the facts you go look at rivals then get back at me with facts not what u think Denzel perryman 3 star was better than any fsu lb they had when he came out them same year I ask u to do me a favor please go look at rivals from 2005 until now and u will see my point true the had a couple of guys who was good i can name them but look how many 5 star bust they had Jr Bryant played 4 years at fsu and didn't not have a pick how in the **** and please go and look it up i promise you that they have had more 5 star bust do that favor for me go and look then come back with all of the names that's was 5 stars and u will see fred rouse was on there to anyone from miami Broward or palm beach the got that was a 5 or 4 star they got off
 
Advertisement
cooperb23583 said:
Lol josh sweat really this dude did nothing for fsu nothing think about all of the good de they had he wouldn't even play for Mickey ... james lol 1 good year freshman year jJ had better stats then him and he didn't get a invite to the awards show but he did lol james was trash last year could not jJ jock strap dalvin cook was a beast also he from dade and I'm sure that he was a 4 star coming out check the facts you go look at rivals then get back at me with facts not what u think Denzel perryman 3 star was better than any fsu lb they had when he came out them same year I ask u to do me a favor please go look at rivals from 2005 until now and u will see my point true the had a couple of guys who was good i can name them but look how many 5 star bust they had Jr Bryant played 4 years at fsu and didn't not have a pick how in the **** and please go and look it up i promise you that they have had more 5 star bust do that favor for me go and look then come back with all of the names that's was 5 stars and u will see fred rouse was on there to anyone from miami Broward or palm beach the got that was a 5 or 4 star they got off
Click to expand...

LMAO your telling me to come back with the facts? You are the one pulling **** out of nowhere. Here is Dalvins profile. 5 star you dumb mf. Your point is not true. So you named 2 5 stars busts. We can go that route. I will name 100 3 star busts from FSU over the past 10 years. Dalvin Cook, Minnesota, Running Back
 
Novacane32000 said:
I know the star rating has been argued back and forth and I hope we are the exception but championship teams will typically have more than half the roster as 4/5 Star players. We are at 41%, though the last 2 CMR classes are 55%, so trending the right way.

As it stands right now 10 of our 22 starters will have 4 +stars (We may add a couple with the 2018 class)

Defense-Bandy, MJack, JJack, Willis, Shaq (I used Rivals so Jaquan is 3 stars on that site)
Offense-Tyree STL,Donaldson,AR,JT,Cager

We are close but need to stay on a roll recruiting wise to play with the big boys.
Click to expand...
Sorry man lose all credibility if you use rivals
 
Advertisement
OriginalGatorHater said:
LMAO your telling me to come back with the facts? You are the one pulling **** out of nowhere. Here is Dalvins profile. 5 star you dumb mf. Your point is not true. So you named 2 5 stars busts. We can go that route. I will name 100 3 star busts from FSU over the past 10 years. Dalvin Cook, Minnesota, Running Back
Click to expand...
Lol ok ok cook was and got off again fsu have had a bunch of 5 stars did nothing again u like number u look rivals go search and look back from 2005 and tell me cause idk what u are saying
 
2Focusd804 said:
Defense actually avg the exact same 90.45 as offense. obviously some of these are different MJ is def playing better than an 88, no way we can consider Willis a 98 at this point but this is based strictly off recruiting rank.

5/11 4*(+) 45%

DE: J. Jackson- 4* (94)
DT: Willis- 5* (98)
DT: Bethel- 3* (87)
DE: D. Jackson 4* (90)
Striker: Finley- 3* (87)
LB: Quarterman- 4* (93)
LB: Pickney- 3* (89)
CB: MJ- 3* (88)
FS: Redwine- 3* (88)
SS: Jaquan Johnson- 4* (93)
CB: Bandy- 3* (88)
Click to expand...

I could have sworn Bandy was a 4 star. That surprised me.
 
cooperb23583 said:
Lol ok ok cook was and got off again fsu have had a bunch of 5 stars did nothing again u like number u look rivals go search and look back from 2005 and tell me cause idk what u are saying
Click to expand...

Are you ******* with me? You can't understand what I'm saying? You are typing like my 8 year old nephew and you can't comprehend my point? I will break it down for you.

FSU has had a few 5 stars that ended up being scrubs. FSU has had 100 3 stars that ended up being scrubs. Do you get it now?
 
Advertisement
Back
Top