Give me a great talent evaluator, forget the recruiting nonsense, talent evaluator is first and foremost. They can have all the stars they want or not have any, history has shown the best teams are the ones that find the guys that best fit their schemes regardless of stars.
It is hilarious to read these "experts" critique, on one hand "not getting the studs" on the other hand they will say a "3 star from South Florida is a 4 or 5 star anywhere else" . That is all BS, it is about evaluating the players and finding the best guy they believe will fit their scheme the best for an optimum opportunity to succeed. And yes now this will go down to the stars do or don't matter BS. UM has always lost some of the top rated talent locally to other schools, they always will regardless of how great we are, history has shown that.
Just give me an organization that evaluates the talent properly for their schemes, and then give me a great coach. You have those two things and recruiting is never an issue. Times may change, but certain things never do, and these two things have always been a constant throughout football, regardless of what is available now, whether it be star system or hudl or pro football focus or whatever analytics they use.