Your "Jim Thorpe" award photo above is actually just for Gabe Taylor being named as the best DB for ONE game only, ie that particular week, as determined by the sponsor of the award (Paycom).
He certainly has NOT won the actual Jim Thorpe award; that award is given out later at the end of the season.
In fact he's NOT even listed as one of the 12 semifinalistd for the actual annual Jim Thorpe award.
Looks like the game in question was against a 5-3 UAB team ranked 65th in the nation. Good for him regardless.
Hindsight / I told you so posts are easy to type; there's times when perhaps we should have offered just as there's also plenty of times we should be glad that we didn't offer. Can't say we screwed up though.
Let's see how it plays out over the next few seasons. As just a few examples remember G Hall flashed tor maybe a couple of games a couple years back. Now he just gets criticized. Bolden too had an awesome game or 1/2 a game last year but hasn't appeared to keep up that same level (and unfortunately now he's hurt).
Don't know Taylor but wish him well. Don't however see UM as ******** up by not offering him.